Repertoire of behaviorally informed interventions go beyond nudges. E.g. sugar tax, other mandates. Which to choose? Highest net benefits usually (cost benefits). Choice preserving efforts should be to priority. @CassSunstein #BX2018
-
-
Question: what approaches work for different ethnic or racial or socioeconomic groups? A: Parent Academy: one group- Hispanics- have greatest benefits (relative to Black and White groups in Chicago). They have more family networks to cover when one parent can't make it.
#BX2018Show this thread -
'Welfare effect' needs to be analysed when measuring the benefits of a study/ trial. E.g. what if teachers hate what's required to achieve the 'claw back effect,' even if their students' outcomes improve? Need to address and measure this. - John List
#BX2018Show this thread -
1/2. Q from SMH journalist: will rich White people benefit from this approach? A: 90% kids in the trial are below poverty line. Rest 10% variable SES - but they also improve. 'We want every child to reach their potential.' John List
#BX2018Show this thread -
2/2. In general population, high SES kids already meet their potential more often while low SES kids are being left behind. As a society, we're missing out on their potential, their outputs. Using
#BehaviouralScience to take them from not having a chance to having chance.#BX2018Show this thread -
Next session: second generation nudges. What are the next areas of behavioural interventions in social policy? First up Prof
@dilipsoman#BehaviouralScience is more than nudges. Choice architecture, design, market for self control, better decision-making.#poc#marginscipic.twitter.com/naEUhWtnz8
Show this thread -
How do we build behaviorally informed organisations? Basic example issue is, how do we get people to read social media privacy policies? What is our role as behavioural scientists? From problem solver
auditor
designer
chief strategist. @dilipsoman#BX2018pic.twitter.com/MMno9deYSc
Show this thread -
Now Kate Phillips. Most
#BehaviouralScience insights in social policy have been applied in implementation and evaluation. Eg. Behaviourally informed text messages for vaccinations and hospital reminders and fact sheets for consumers.#BX2018pic.twitter.com/9kBbcAOUeL – at International Convention Centre Sydney (ICC)
Show this thread -
We now need to move into using
#BehaviouralScience to policy creation. But how? Randomised control trials can't be used to generate policy. Use counterfactuals - apply BI principles to policy design. Eg cigarette packages. - Kate Phillips#BX2018pic.twitter.com/2NipOC2AHn
Show this thread -
#BehaviouralScience policy design used in Victoria to improve information sharing between front line workers in domestic family violence. They value empowering survivors. Physical barriers limit info sharing. E.g. sitting behind registrar at court. - Kate Phillips#BX2018#DFVpic.twitter.com/CLtNxdsRvD
Show this thread -
Now Liam Smith- a psychologist who says he will pretend to be a sociologist for his talk! (
)
Systems change theory is useful. Need 3 things to sustain change:
Engaged individuals
Political opportunity
Organisational infrastructure
-Liam Smith #BX2018#sociologypic.twitter.com/cTMi1FKvsS
Show this thread -
#Sociology theory tells us that most traditional#BehaviouralScience nudges hurt structure and agency. But can be used to improve 'second generation' tools to improve moral and social licence to take action. Eg. Where attitudes are weak - workplace safety - Liam Smith#BX2018pic.twitter.com/voFY4vprRs
Show this thread -
Where attitudes are strong, focus on behavioural changes that are simple but effective. Reinforce identity and self efficacy to shift attitudes. E.g. water saving behaviour. - Liam Smith
#BX2018pic.twitter.com/wLBokQlZbh
Show this thread -
Now Elizabeth Hardy from Canada. Their first gen
#BehaviouralScience policy work was on traditional touch points (emails or phone calls) that increased public participation in surveys and charitable giving. Then worked on educational savings incentive trials.#BX2018pic.twitter.com/RIZ8CZtE0U
Show this thread -
Second generation nudges: in March, the Canadian team trialled adding education savings to existing birth bundle, only 20 minute online process. Next will move to trial letters from principals to parents, as well as offering via social assistance. - Elizabeth Hardy
#BX2018pic.twitter.com/xuPdPLJs3B
Show this thread -
Panel Q&A. We need to move away from talking about 'failed' trials. Whether the intervention worked as we intended or not, we still learned something valuable. -
@dilipsoman#BX2018Show this thread -
Nudges can be thought of in 2 ways. 1/ systemic changes (simple nudges). 2/ Different sub-groups. Need different nudges or approaches. E.g. superannuation calculator to help individuals weigh up individual choices to make decision on their preferred plan.
@dilipsoman#BX2018Show this thread -
Q: future areas to apply second gen
#BehaviouralScience tools: >Social cohesion >Preventative health.#BX2018Show this thread -
Next session: 'fire side chat'
@CassSunstein & Tara Oliver, Managing Director@beta_gov_au How 'Nudge' was born: a fairytale. In early 1980s@CassSunstein was an English major battling 'monsters chanting "People are rational."' Best description of classical economics!
#BX2018Show this thread -
#BehaviouralScience insights of#StarWars! No matter what nudges we receive, either from Sith or Jedi, people have a choice. Another theme from the films that relate to BI is that a parent would do anything to save their children. -@CassSunstein with Tara Oliver.#BX2018pic.twitter.com/1EPY15RD5Z
Show this thread -
1/2 Nudging the nudgers: how do we stop policy makers from falling prey to their biases (i.e. choice architecture for choice architects)? 1/ public consultation 'is NOT Kabuki theatre.' It matters. People read comments others make. Can't ignore them.
@CassSunstein#BX2018Show this thread -
2/2 Nudging the nudgers: 2/ Invest in cost benefit analyses 3/ Maintain scientific integrity 4/ Commit to retrospective analysis. Learn after fact how any intervention is going.
@CassSunstein#BX2018Show this thread -
Q: Tech can use nudges in ways that may 'cost' Gov. E.g. apps that help you avoid parking fines means less revenue A: Cost benefit analysis should be for social good/ public interest. Fines shouldn't be about revenue. It's to help us comply with law.
@CassSunstein#BX2018Show this thread -
Policymakers need to weigh up social costs vs social benefits for the public good.
@CassSunstein#BX2018Show this thread -
Q: Is Trump administration still committed to
#BehaviouralScience as the Obama administration? A: Yes. Calorie labels. Food safety and nutrition work. Are subsidies and mandates still being used in current climate? Yes says@CassSunstein Gov agencies continue this work.#BX2018Show this thread -
Manipulation by deception of consumers is outlawed by many countries. Some governments still use manipulation edging towards deception. E.g. health nudges. We need to think further on this.
@CassSunstein#BX2018Show this thread -
1/2 How can we follow
@CassSunstein's first point on bill of rights for nudging when everyone's values and interests can be different? A: if it's an 'easy' issue, by using personalised preferences. If it's complicated issue do cost/benefit & address people's losses.#BX2018Show this thread -
2/2 E.g. use reminders or easy opt outs for people to minimise their losses. -
@CassSunstein#BX2018Show this thread
End of conversation
New conversation -
Loading seems to be taking a while.
Twitter may be over capacity or experiencing a momentary hiccup. Try again or visit Twitter Status for more information.