Hey @YouTube and @YTCreators, @WarnerChappell ! My counter-notification for my Single Ladies analysis DMCA takedown was rejected. What documented evaluation was done on the video that ruled out fair use? Lenz v. Universal Music Corp., 801 F.3d 1126 requires this.
There's margin of ambiguity, and then there's just plain unclear. "It appears you do not have the rights to post" almost sounds like even *they* aren't sure what you violated. Is an itemized list too much to ask for? They're not even giving clues for potential remedies.