(THREAD) The tax bill that just passed the Senate is terrible policy. But Republicans are right that passing it is better for them politically than failure. Here's why:
-
-
Parts of the Republican base are ideologically committed to tax cuts above all else. They can ignore failure in every other area, but not this one. No tax cuts would've left them disillusioned. They'd never vote Democrat, but they might choose not to volunteer. Or vote. 3/x
Show this thread -
An unfortunately high number of Americans treat politics like sports. My team rules, your team sucks. Details irrelevant. They'll celebrate this "win," and would've been discouraged by a loss. That encourages volunteers and turnout, and reduces chances of primary challenges. 4/x
Show this thread -
The bill screws over a lot of working and middle class Americans, including some Trump brought into the party. But how many of them will care? The pain doesn't really kick in for a few years. And the media/politicians they trust will say it helps them. Most will believe it. 5/x
Show this thread -
Democrats are already as motivated as they can be. Passing a big tax cut that almost exclusively helps rich people will motivate them. But so would trying, but failing, to pass a big tax cut that almost exclusively helps rich people. 6/x
Show this thread -
This doesn't change any of the criticisms of the bill's substance. It's not regular order, which McCain said matters. It's not close to deficit-neutral (even when assuming big economic growth), which Flake said matters. It'll make premiums go up, which Collins said matters. 7/x
Show this thread -
It's poorly constructed, deficit-financed stimulus at the exact wrong point in the business cycle. But the likely effect is a short-term boost. That's politically advantageous for 2018. Maybe the bubble won't pop until after 2020. (If it does, they'll blame something else). 8/x
Show this thread -
The Republican tax bill is basically a no-money down ballooning interest rate mortgage. It's a terrible idea in the long-run. But the immediate effects should be pretty nice. 9/x
Show this thread -
That's donors, ideologues, and politics-as-sports voters happy. And few besides Democrats unhappy. At least in the short term. The policy is bad for millions of Americans and for the country as a whole. But politically, passing it was better for Republicans than failure. (END)
Show this thread
End of conversation
New conversation -
-
-
Not going to help them now, vote them all out. I watched them all vote Nay on making middle class tax break permanent#vote blue
Thanks. Twitter will use this to make your timeline better. UndoUndo
-
Loading seems to be taking a while.
Twitter may be over capacity or experiencing a momentary hiccup. Try again or visit Twitter Status for more information.