Not getting on the Supreme Court isn’t a punishment. If Kavanaugh withdraws or gets voted down, he won’t be thrown in jail or even fined. Treating Christine Blasey Ford's accusation of sexual assault like a court case applies the wrong standard. My latest:https://arcdigital.media/everyones-applying-the-wrong-standard-to-kavanaugh-s-nomination-9b5859209039?source=friends_link&sk=4973bf2f07aec042d2ede336c92a5dca …
I think you're underestimating how much has changed since Thomas. Not least because of Garland. You also seem to be assuming that Kavanaugh is definitely innocent, when the only honest answer is don't know. If he did it, it's not a hit job, but a genuine accusation.
-
-
Haha you underestimated my move ;). I made the point about the risk of dems using dirty tricks like this to derail any nom. You said “I heard that about Thomas.” Right, so I put my concern back on the table. On Kav, I’m not sure you understand how weak “I don’t know” is.
-
It's the only honest answer. How can you or I or any other outside observers know with anything approaching certainty?
-
We know very little “approaching certainty.” So that’s uninteresting. In terms of probabilities, I put it very low. But if “knowing approaching certainty” is your standard, then guess what, you don’t know if Pizzagate is false. lol
-
In terms of probabilities that Blasey Ford is telling the truth, you think it's very low? Do I understand that correctly?
-
Then I think we've reached agree-to-disagree territory. But I'm curious, why do you think that? Do you think she made it up, or just that she's mistaken? Based on what?
-
Yes, we may be. But it’s interesting because I think your post isn’t *really* about risk, but value weighting or prioritizing. So I don’t think your standard works as s way forward. Maybe someplace I can lay out my reasons but would take more than one tweet
-
That's fair. I meant the NatSec comparison as an analogy, not an identical comparison.
- 2 more replies
New conversation -
Loading seems to be taking a while.
Twitter may be over capacity or experiencing a momentary hiccup. Try again or visit Twitter Status for more information.