1/ I’ve been noticing a ubiquitous technique recently upon which I have seen little commented. “Punchable face”, #killallmen, “Open Borders”, “Tax is Theft”, “Believe Women”, “Free markets”, “Free Speech” and uptalking are examples. I want to explain here what I see linking them.
-
Show this thread
-
2/ The technique involves bundling an attacking position and a retreating position where the retreat is low cost and reasonable while the attack is wildly simplistic, irresponsible and generally too expensive to maintain. The attack is frequently literal & the retreat figurative.
13 replies 15 retweets 203 likesShow this thread -
3/ As
@ezraklein pointed out for the attack position#KillAllMen dripping with sexism & misandry, the retreat position is “it would be nice if the world sucked less for women”. Likewise “Open Borders” can collapse all the way down to “I don’t want to see immigrants scapegoated”.pic.twitter.com/ldMxgXH6ZS
9 replies 17 retweets 187 likesShow this thread -
4/ Uptalking seems to be a speech pattern that has, among other benefits, figured out how to make an aggressive statement which would normally be costly in the underlying text for the price of just kinda maybe sorta asking a much less expensive (leading) question with one’s tone.
1 reply 13 retweets 172 likesShow this thread -
5/ “Tax is theft” is a broad clean insane attack on nationhood, but if you bring up the problem of military protection as a well known public good & market defect, you get told that “Tax is Teft” is just a plea for smaller more prudent government. Okay. So why are we doing this?
34 replies 13 retweets 161 likesShow this thread -
6/ In the previous examples, the literal position has been the aggressive one, but that’s not even always true. Sometime I hear “Feminism is simply the proposition that women are equal.” which would be the retreat position with which only a loon would be tempted to argue.
7 replies 9 retweets 151 likesShow this thread -
7/ Let’s call amalgams of attack and retreat Split-Level Arguments. We need to stop allowing these gambits to go unnoticed. They are like Navy SEALS dressed up as adorable toddlers. If you‘re advancing “Free Markets”, pay the price for the simplicity you just bought when pressed.
7 replies 11 retweets 168 likesShow this thread -
End/ Let’s come up with language to make it very expensive to repeatedly push for something simple, clear & wrong as if we were just saying something reasonable & nuanced. If you’ve noticed this trend, send me examples or anyone else’s name for it. Thx!
#SplitLevelArguments36 replies 24 retweets 329 likesShow this thread -
Replying to @EricRWeinstein
This is mostly just Motte & Bailey, is it not? https://slatestarcodex.com/2014/11/03/all-in-all-another-brick-in-the-motte/ …
1 reply 0 retweets 4 likes -
This Tweet is unavailable.
Loading seems to be taking a while.
Twitter may be over capacity or experiencing a momentary hiccup. Try again or visit Twitter Status for more information.