Hypothesis: Real Peer Review can be described, after @Meaningness, as a sensible stage-4 rationalist criticism of people aspiring to a (admittedly, sometimes pseudo-, in Chapman's words, but usually also sensible) pomo-like stage 4.5.
https://meaningness.com/metablog/stem-fluidity-bridge …
Glad you liked it… I’m pretty distant from university system, so don’t have an opinion about which ones do the best job