Profound debate, also excellent fun, about the most difficult, important question in the philosophy of mind. My two favorite cognitive scientists, Brian Cantwell Smith and @vervaeke_john, arguing opposite sides
h/t @JakeOrthweinhttps://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Lpu7766Rlks&feature=youtu.be …
-
-
Brian’s central point is that we can think about (and be conscious of?) concerns we’re not currently causally connected to; so an interactivist, causal theory cannot be fully adequate. Which is importantly true! So how do we do that? Representation, says Brian…
Show this thread -
But, we know the representationalist story can’t work, for a host of reasons, each individually fatal—as Brian acknowledges. Some other account of representation is required; he’s devoted decades to working one out. I’m not sure I understand it; I tend to doubt it works, but…
Show this thread -
Brian’s theory of representation is sufficiently radical that it requires fundamental rethinking of the nature of computation; and here I think he’s right. Semi-relevantly, from my 1986 paper with Phil Agre: https://meaningness.com/metablog/abstract-emergent …pic.twitter.com/uKq4Nt5l4o
Show this thread -
Around the middle of the video, John and Brian find that they are in violent agreement on many substantive points, where both strongly disagree with traditional cognitivism. Here I am in strong agreement with both of them (and reiterate my customary disdain for mainstream cogsci)
Show this thread -
They end by agreeing that much of the difficulty is in the nebulosity of both “consciousness” and “representation.” It’s tempting to dismiss the issues as hopelessly vague. But important; so their hashing out conflicting understandings is valuable (and fascinating!).
Show this thread
End of conversation
New conversation -
-
-
Awakened awareness aware of itself the non-dual states
-
I think that’s what he was talking about, yes!
- 2 more replies
New conversation -
-
-
I don't think people can be "intensely" conscious/aware because of hard limits on the cognitive substrate (brain matter), and in being not conscious of anything implies zombie mode (with a realization of a gap where "you" didn't exist for a time).
Thanks. Twitter will use this to make your timeline better. UndoUndo
-
Loading seems to be taking a while.
Twitter may be over capacity or experiencing a momentary hiccup. Try again or visit Twitter Status for more information.