For a long time I thought ppl were saying dumb things about rationality, until I realized they were using a different definition of rationality from me. I think their definition is something like "If social consensus is that an idea is unpromising, then that idea is irrational"https://twitter.com/paulg/status/1090608908534800384 …
-
Show this thread
-
That definition of rationality leads to people saying things like... "Steve Jobs had the irrational belief that people could finish a project really fast if they tried. They didn't believe him, but he kept turning out to be right. That proves that irrationality can be beneficial"
6 replies 2 retweets 76 likesShow this thread -
The definition I'd been using is the decision science one -- forming beliefs about the world as accurately as you can, given your priors & the information available to you (epistemic rationality), and making decisions that maximize your expected utility (instrumental rationality)
10 replies 9 retweets 148 likesShow this thread -
Admittedly, under that definition, it's tricky to know for sure if someone's beliefs or decisions are rational. It's more of a normative ideal than an easily applicable criterion you can use to judge people's actual beliefs/decisions.
4 replies 2 retweets 61 likesShow this thread -
It's tricky because, e.g., you don't know what someone's utility function is. They might be more risk-seeking than you, or derive more utility from working on a weird/cool/unique project than you do. A decision that would be irrational for you might be rational for them.
11 replies 2 retweets 75 likesShow this thread -
Oh, another definition ppl use is "A decision is rational iff you can explain why it's good in a way that will make sense to other people." Problem is, our beliefs about the world are based on intuitions developed over years of experience, which we can't easily articulate
5 replies 1 retweet 107 likesShow this thread -
Anyway, all of this is part of why I've been increasingly avoiding the word "rational". Too many hard-to-resolve misunderstandings.
20 replies 4 retweets 112 likesShow this thread
Reflecting on this, and wondering if I should do likewise. What alternatives or workarounds have you come up with? (So far the best I’ve managed is to define “rational” explicitly and draw distinctions with several related concepts, eg “mere reasonableness.)
Loading seems to be taking a while.
Twitter may be over capacity or experiencing a momentary hiccup. Try again or visit Twitter Status for more information.