Matt Semite

A tough road. I've always been interested in people like you. Is your eventual goal to live among other Ashkenazis or assimilate to white America?

That's a good question. I'm an American and it's where my loyalties are, so my hopes are to remain in an America that becomes increasingly demographically white, as that's where I've always felt most at home.

For a one off I have no problem, but regression to the mean with all things seems to be an issue as well as a group selection within jewish community for those most sensitive to anti-Semitism will cause problems. Honest question, have you ever thought of making Aliya?

There was a time when I considered it, but I have no cultural or linguistic connection to Israel. I visited once on a birthright trip years ago and it was a nice vacation spot but nowhere I could see myself living.

As for regression to the mean, that's valid and something I've thought about. Anecdotally, my whole family is pretty far-right, so for whatever reason we've had a few generations of people kind of like me ideologically. I'm also engaged to a gentile woman for what it's worth

Well that answers the assimilation question I suppose. Real life is messy. Anyone supporting nationalism for us is at worst an ally imo.

Messy indeed my friend.

Best of luck with your engagement. Have lots of goy children lol.

On the ethno-nationalist for Israel argument. Ethno-nationalism is fine, unless we put it on a land that belongs to another ethnicity. Why can't polish jews be part of polish ethno-nationalism for example? Syrian jews for Syria etc.

When you say "on a land that belongs to another ethnicity" where do we draw the line? Should Americans return their land to the natives? What about Australians? I like what you say in theory but seems impossible to implement

That happened several 100 years ago, the colonisation of native Palestine is happening right now and we can stop it. This is where we draw a line. Traditional european states are ethno-states, "german" is an ethnicity, but "american" isn't an ethnicity.

I'm not particularly concerned with the plight of the Israelis or Palestinians one way or another. Let them sort it out amongst themselves. Neither side seems to offer much to Americans. Just keep our troops and money out of it

American troops have died for (partial list) France, the UK, Italy, Saudi Arabia, Kuwait, Iraq, Syria, Lebanon, Haiti, Nicaragua, Korea, Vietnam and Panama, never once Israel. The money given in foreign military aid is spent in the US on American products.

bs...Israel bombed the USS Liberty killing 34 US sailors injuring another 171. The Iraq war was solely for Israel and push by that neocon PNAC cabal & AIPAC. Read the Clean Break paper.

1/ 1. At any point you can drop your white identity and simply be Jewish. 2. You can write a book and go on tour about your time as a/among the "racists" and "antisemites" etc.—and make lots of money doing it, as others have done before you. ...

1/ Frankly it would be much easier for me to do the inverse 2/ I suppose I *could*, just as you could do some tour of how you're a "reformed nazi" or whatever. But my impression is neither one of us have any inclination to do so.

Point 1: You have much to gain identifying as Jewish and very little to gain identifying as white. Point 2: my people don't have a massively disproportionate history of betraying European societies and nationalists. That changes things.

I've never really understood this. In the conventional narrative (Nazis = jew-hating monsters) how does this make sense? In the alternative narrative (Nazis = jew-aware patriots) how does this make sense? How could they be confident they were trustworthy & weren't ((agents))?

Q of loyalty & identification: 'Mischlinge' who didn't identify as/with Semites weren't considered Jewish Another Q: Why fraternize w/someone who identifies as a full-blooded Semite & w/the criminal Semitic ME entity? Someone who's a proven liar??Not exactly a Bobby Fischer

Not sure if you're addressing me... Who is the "proven liar" you're referring to?

Do you have a response, Matt?

To what? Golden Laughter blocked me

He posted a tweet of yours saying your family were Argentinian and a pic of your avi & location stating "Haifa, Israel". He's suggesting you're being dishonest and said there were other examples.