Maya Forstater

@PaulJMonaghan - can you comment on the directors' loans question? Where does FTM see it in terms of the tax avoidance/fair tax/boring tax planning spectrum?

Hi Paul. You commented over the weekend on the tax affairs of a coffee company FTM has not certified, can you comment on this question on a company that has been? -- helpful to clarify what the substantive criteria for 'ok' and 'not ok' is for FTM.

No thanks Maya. Am doing my best not to engage with polemics right now. Life"s too short

It's a question not a polemic. Seems like a reasonable question for @FairTaxMark to have a view on. It must have come up in the certification process for @AMTCoffee? Or Technical Committee? @alexcobham @_DavidQuentin @RichardJMurphy

It's a question from a polemicist - someone who regularly rips into NGOs on governance, but has little to say on what's emerging at the IoD. Someone who has the time to critique contributions of the third sector but rarely comments on the misdemenours of the Big Four.

That seems unfair to me. Maya works in development so naturally that is the area she engages in. She is often challenging but always polite. Surely you should welcome and engage in genuine debate, even if you don’t happen to like the questioner?

But its not genuine debate Heather. If it was I would engage - within reason. The question is tied up with mean-spirited stuff from a couple of weeks ago that I took issue with. Anyhow, work to do...

But the mystery remains - why did Fair Tax Mark okay a company with two significant questions: the director loans and the possible profit-shifting. At this point it looks like you didn't consider these.