123 people signed a letter in @thesundaytimes congratulating @UKScouting for reviewing its transgender guidance. Lets look at the changes (
= concerns on old guidance, 
/
/
= good/ok/not good on new guidance)
Show this thread
-
Who are the Gender Trust you ask? Its hard to tell. Last time i looked it had not filed returns with the Charity Commission for 5 years. It was recently removed as 'ceased to exist' https://beta.charitycommission.gov.uk/charity-details/?regid=1088150&subid=0 …
Show this thread
It seems to have been associated with a transgender therapist Shelly Bridgman https://genderidentity.co.uk/ who says " I may be one of the few therapists to truly understand what you are going through"
-
-
In the new Guidance the Gender Trust is removed
and Mermaids is relegated to "may be useful info" . Gendered Intelligence, Stonewall and GIRES are added as links, but there are no links to NHS resources or organisations sceptical of gender ideology Show this thread -
The old guidance encouraged breast binding
as a practice that must be respected. This has been removed from the new guidance . But it does not mention that breast binding might be a cause for concern pic.twitter.com/tdPiosATip
Show this thread -
The old guidance was big on the idea that children should be treated as having and knowing their "true gender"
rather than experiencing dysphoria which they might cope with or which might resolve in different ways.pic.twitter.com/1vcXC7C5tZ
Show this thread -
Cross sex hormone treatment was presented as the obvious option
"allowing their body to develop in the way of their true gender"Show this thread -
The new guidance is more cautious.
Listen without making judgements or assumptions. Ask what you can do to make the child more comfortable. Give children time to think about it. Make adjustments to include them.pic.twitter.com/1ulWVDKDpn
Show this thread -
The old guidance undermined safeguarding by telling volunteers they should reassure of “complete confidentiality”
. The new guidance has more emphasis on safeguarding & makes clear that information can be shared if volunteers have concerns for a child's welfare or safety Show this thread -
The old guidance barely mentioned parents
. Only saying to work with them "if supportive" [of transition]. . It set the scene for viewing parents who are not encouraging their child to transition as prejudiced. .pic.twitter.com/3QgTWwPkS4
Show this thread -
The new guidance has more emphasise on encouraging scouts to talk to parents, and involving them in planning together.
But it says parents should only be informed with child's permission (.... this should say unless there are concerns for child's welfare or safety!)pic.twitter.com/PmNTfZtiSc
Show this thread -
The old guidance says "ideally" children should use cubicled facilities of their "true gender" (i.e. shared with children of the opposite sex). It doesn't mention anything about the privacy and comfort of the other children.
pic.twitter.com/ubEnGy8oxM
Show this thread -
The new guidance suggests a range of practical options for ensuring everyone feels comfortable
pic.twitter.com/phLV4mO7yR
Show this thread -
You can read my assessment
@Transgendertrd https://www.transgendertrend.com/scout-association-new-transgender-guidance-big-step-forward/ … and see the new guidance here https://members.scouts.org.uk/supportresources/4228/supporting-trans-young-people?cat=377,378&moduleID=10 …Show this thread
End of conversation
New conversation -
Loading seems to be taking a while.
Twitter may be over capacity or experiencing a momentary hiccup. Try again or visit Twitter Status for more information.