In which I get a comedy review from Graham Linehan....
. As friends will know I'm not very good at funny, but yes read these questions and non-answers out loud, you have to laugh or you might cry at the Minister for Women refusing to give a straight answer to what a woman is. https://twitter.com/Glinner/status/1107359745663557634 …
-
-
Which shows the problem with this debate (and lots of debates). No one has got enough time to think through all the issues of the day so we all triangulate against what our tribe says, and organise people into 'goodies' and 'baddies'.
Show this thread -
Anyway, this is what i said to my friend. People mock and belittle each other on the internet all the time. I don't think Graham mocks a particular class of people, he mocks specific people who are being arseholes.
Show this thread -
Trans people who are 'allied' w him include
@DebbieHayton@KJ_Harrison@Rose_Of_Dawn@FionneOrlander@Jenny_Randles@Kinesis @LTranssexual Miranda Yardley, Seven Hex (the last two thrown off twitter for 'misgendering').Show this thread -
Anyway I signed the letter of support a while backhttps://www.feministcurrent.com/2019/02/28/open-letter-in-support-of-graham-linehans-challenges-to-gender-identity-ideology/ …
Show this thread -
Take a look at people such as Alison Moyet, Rose McGowan & Jenni Murray who have tried to publicly disagree or challenge the ideology of gender identity have been bullied off the internet or into capitulation. And within organisations, privately, this is happening all the time.
Show this thread -
Take a look at the Anthony Watson trying to bully Graham Linehan and then turning his sights on The Economists' @HJJoyceEcon after publicly complaining about her views to her employer last week https://twitter.com/janeclarejones/status/1107031217952776192 …
This Tweet is unavailable.Show this thread -
Calling people names, saying "you can't align with them, they are evil" or it might make you unemployable, is a strategy used to isolate and silence people, and to make it too costly for others to even take the time to think about the issue.
Show this thread -
This is a serious policy and legal issue, and we should be able to talk about it openly, carefully and compassionately. It shouldn't be being battled out in twitter spats and personal insults (although there is always a place for comedy and disrespect in keeping democracies open)
Show this thread -
The problem is that the organisations that should be holding open the space for polite, careful, patient debate & evidence: the established women's rights orgs, NSPCC, human rights orgs,
@EHRC @WomenEqualities, think tanks, academia, the media, MPs etc are not doing their job.Show this thread -
People are scared to talk because "people gonna think you're aligning with a baddie". But the erosion of women's spaces, child safeguarding & women's right to organise autonomously is too important not to. The only way to face it is for more people to stand up for open debate
Show this thread -
I am super grateful to
@Glinner@jackappleby@MichaelConroy68@SimonFanshawe@jonnnybest and@jameskirkup who have stood up for women. And i am super grateful for men and women who have stood up for me (including my friend, who i know has my best interests at heart)Show this thread
End of conversation
New conversation -
Loading seems to be taking a while.
Twitter may be over capacity or experiencing a momentary hiccup. Try again or visit Twitter Status for more information.