Significant figures in human accomplishment over time. Using data from @charlesmurray's great book on the topic. https://www.goodreads.com/book/show/282085.Human_Accomplishment …pic.twitter.com/MUTMKxBUEe
-
imo: v. high quality database but if using to make point u need to know coverage is lacking e.g. central asia
-
-
I looked up names of many Persians, Khursanians, C Asians using spreadsheet and they weren't there
-
The dataset is not supposed to cover everybody. if you think so, you have misunderstood its construction.
@EALTurner@pseudoerasmus
End of conversation
New conversation -
-
-
Lost Enlightenment (Starr 2013) intro to Central Asia before this advanced civilization nuked by Mongols.
-
Thanks. Seems interesting. Will add to my to-read list. :)
@EALTurner@pseudoerasmus -
also check out http://scholar.harvard.edu/chaney/publications/religion-and-rise-and-fall-islamic-science … decline of islamic golden age prob. not due to Mongols!
@EALTurner -
disagree. Central Asia golden age was nuked by Mongels. Islamic golden age is another location - Iraq.
-
Khurasan, Bactria, Sogdiana very important regions for Central Asia. Susiana and Mesopotamia - another place.
-
ok ok Prof. Starr! but my tastes run toward thinking pre-Islamic C. Asia (especially under Sassanids) is more underrated !
-
there was a lot of human capital in Khurasan region during the Central Asian enlightenment. totally separate from Mid East.
-
well Chaney's pre-1500 data seem to agree with your assessment (white circles scientific production, grey=overall book prod)pic.twitter.com/Lw7cIAZwHE
- 3 more replies
New conversation -
Loading seems to be taking a while.
Twitter may be over capacity or experiencing a momentary hiccup. Try again or visit Twitter Status for more information.