Non-farm payrolls print at +2.5 million, which no-one saw coming, suggesting that most private-sector forecasters got the number wrong by 20 MILLION. The unemployment rate is DOWN to 13.3 percent (instead of up to 20% as forecast). There's going to be a lot to unpack here...
-
-
I still can't believe that
@betseystevenson wrote this paragraph a whole month ago. To give context, professional forecasters predicted payrolls would fall by about 8 million this month. (Her whole piece was excellent: https://www.washingtonpost.com/opinions/2020/05/09/job-numbers-are-horrible-theres-more-this-story/ …)pic.twitter.com/ffCB3vtgOr
Show this thread -
This is easily the most important table in the jobs report. Good news: Roughly 3/4 of the rise in unemployment reflects temporary layoffs. There's hope many of these folks will return to work soon. Bad news: Permanent job loss has risen by over a million since Feb.pic.twitter.com/7XFm0FdLrC
Show this thread -
A remarkable fact (that so far has gone unremarked): This month's rise in non-farm payrolls of +2.5 million is (easily!) the largest monthly rise ever recorded. But it's still only one-eighth of last month's monstrous decline of -20.7 million. (Also a record.)
Show this thread -
Over the next few months, we all need to remember that these 3 things can all be true: 1. Covid pushed the economy into a massive hole 2. It's so deep that even just a partial recovery will yield historically unprecedented growth rates 3. The economy is still in a bad bad place
Show this thread -
Or as I would say to my freshman econ students: Don't confuse levels and changes. The changes are going to be dramatic and positive, but that's largely because the levels are even more dramatically negative.
Show this thread -
Lemme put today's surprising jobs numbers in perspective. It's simple arithmetic that when millions of businesses are shuttered that employment will tank, and any reversal will lead jobs to spike. The only real surprise was that the spike started this month, rather than next.
Show this thread -
What do today's numbers tell us about the recovery? Very little, I'm afraid. We knew that a partial unwinding of the shutdown would lead to a partial reversal of job losses. The important question remains how many jobs will resume, and how quickly. That remains unknown.
Show this thread -
Another attempt at perspective. 20 million people lost their jobs, causing unemployment to rise near Depression levels. Today's data says 1-in-8 of those jobs returned. But the real question is what'll happen to the rest? Even if half return we're replaying the Great Recession
Show this thread -
A data point on how (un)informative today's payrolls number was. Stocks rose about 2-3% on the news. That's the sort of response you would see if payrolls were half a million or maybe a million higher than expected. In reality, today's number was 10 million higher than forecast
Show this thread -
Trying to say this in English: If today's jobs numbers caused you to dramatically shift your assessment of the economy, you're doing it wrong. Markets are reacting to today's jobs report as if it were pretty good news, but it's far short of great news and that seems about right.
Show this thread
End of conversation
New conversation -
Loading seems to be taking a while.
Twitter may be over capacity or experiencing a momentary hiccup. Try again or visit Twitter Status for more information.