I don't know what's in Ben Shapiro's heart, but we already agreed there are righteous and wicked people - Jewish and non-Jewish. But it's obvious from history that God has preserved His Jewish people from horrors such as pogroms & the Holocaust & brought them back to the land.
Sons of Abraham is because He believed God before and after circumcision. It doesn't mean we became Israel. Gentile believers in Jesus are not entitled to the land just like Gentle believers in Jesus are not expected to be circumcised or keep a kosher diet. It's not for them.