So granted: they're monsters. But are they the kinds of monsters who would undermine free speech? Herewith, some debunking of myths. Myth #1: Young people in general (and students in particular) don't support free speech.
Show this thread
-
It's not all good news for Free Speech Freakout-skeptics like myself. There's wide variation among students, and greater numbers are willing to support restrictions when faced with concrete scenarios. But I doubt US adults over all would respond very differently.pic.twitter.com/2LuiAVduP6
Show this thread
Myth #2: University makes students less tolerant of offensive speech. Actually, it's the opposite! University makes people MORE tolerant of offensive or opposing viewpoints, not less. Surprised? You probably haven't spoken with many high schoolers lately. They're psychopaths.
-
-
But more seriously, here is some headline data from a survey of over 7,000 students at more than 120 US colleges. After one year of college, a plurality of students reported improved attitudes toward other students with opposing political viewpoints. https://theconversation.com/does-college-turn-people-into-liberals-90905 …pic.twitter.com/a2VWiI2MZL
Show this thread -
And there's more. According to a massive 2009 UCLA study (the most recent I could find with the comparative data), four years of college makes students *less supportive* of banning racist/sexist speech on campus. Wow, college is a moderating force! https://www.heri.ucla.edu/PDFs/pubs/Reports/2009_CSS_Report.pdf …pic.twitter.com/mevS1IYX4w
Show this thread -
And finally... Myth #3: Students may tell pollsters that they support free speech, but their actions show otherwise.
Show this thread -
FIRE has the goods. Out of a country with 4,700 universities, there were 29 attempts in 2017 to disinvite or block an invited speaker from speaking on campus. Twenty-nine…and most of those attempts failed.https://www.thefire.org/resources/disinvitation-database/ …
Show this thread -
Moreover, those that did succeed were more likely to come from the Right, not the Left. So much for the tolerant Right!https://heterodoxacademy.org/campus-speaker-disinvitations-recent-trends-part-2-of-2/ …
Show this thread -
(Oh, and FIRE reports a strong and steady decline in the number of universities with formal speech codes as well.) https://d28htnjz2elwuj.cloudfront.net/wp-content/uploads/2017/11/02103107/Annual_Report_2017.pdf …pic.twitter.com/vKNE1HmIuH
Show this thread -
Now, some of you may be wondering why, if there is no campus free speech crisis, we keep hearing about one. I have my suspicions, having to do with a mix of false nostalgia, anti-elitism, and the distorting effects of social media. But I want to suggest another reason as well.
Show this thread -
Universities only look like unique hotbeds of anti-free speech sentiment because most adults have no idea how much censorship they themselves are subject to. I mean think about it: where do you spend 90% of your time outside of the house?
Show this thread -
If it's the workplace, have I got some bad news for you: https://www.npr.org/templates/story/story.php?storyId=123024596 … https://www.americanbar.org/publications/insights_on_law_andsociety/15/winter-2015/chill-around-the-water-cooler.html …https://www.newyorker.com/books/page-turner/are-bosses-dictators …
Show this thread -
The point? Well, maybe the reason so many working adults roll their eyes at student outrage over offensive speech is because their employers exert massive private sector coercion to shield them from it. Unlike students, they've forgotten what it's like in the real world.
Show this thread -
(Incidentally, this is also why it would be disastrous for the Left to dismiss private sector censorship on the grounds that, because it's not state-based, it doesn't count. That, my friends, is the Private Life of Power.) http://coreyrobin.com/2012/03/20/the-private-life-of-power/ …
Show this thread -
So, quick summary: There is no campus free speech crisis, the kids are all right, those that say otherwise have lost all perspective, and the real crisis may be elsewhere. But they are still monsters.
Show this thread -
[Correction: My summary of data from FIRE is out of date, with more reports probably coming in since Jan. 1st. The current # of dis-invitations for 2017 stands at thirty-five. Mea culpa, and thanks to
@politicalmath for catching that.]Show this thread
End of conversation
New conversation -
-
-
Oh they "tolerate" real well They "tolerate" people repeatedly in many of those protest. Just like they "tolerated" Richard Spencer in the face.
Thanks. Twitter will use this to make your timeline better. UndoUndo
-
-
-
Thanks. Twitter will use this to make your timeline better. UndoUndo
-
-
-
High school kids are psychopaths, elementary school kids are sociopaths, and middle school kids are the worst!
-
Middle school girls are the worst Boys, meh. Biggest thing I encountered was being told by my daughter’s teacher that girls shouldnt wear skirts b/c middle sch boys didn’t learn to be gentlemen over the summer. They let girls go up the stairs 1st so they can see their underwater
-
Jeffrey, thank you for such an excellent thread. This tweet made me laugh out loud.
End of conversation
New conversation -
Loading seems to be taking a while.
Twitter may be over capacity or experiencing a momentary hiccup. Try again or visit Twitter Status for more information.