〈 Berger | Dillon 〉

Here’s a weird disagreement in fundamental physics: you’ll often hear that general relativity is incompatible with quantum mechanics, but some physicists will tell you that this is outdated. They say that we can quantize general relativity, and specify its low energy EFT.

We can, in fact, get a low energy effective field theory for quantized general relativity (that’s a mouthful). But I think this is a case of physicists talking past each other. When we say that GR and QM are incompatible, we tend to have their physical content in mind.

The low energy EFT is just classical gravity as a background field

Yeah, that’s one of the pieces of ‘physical content’ I had in mind. Background independence is very rich in substance, and simply applying quantization methods successfully doesn’t make the problem go away.

http://www.scholarpedia.org/article/Quantum_gravity_as_a_low_energy_effective_field_theory … relevant

Yeah Donoghue is exactly who I had in mind. I really enjoy his stuff but I think this one part isn’t handled too carefully lol