1. So I have some thoughts on Jordan Peterson, vintage clothing, George Eliot, Carl Jung, comparative mythology, fascism, the Indiana Jones movies, ancient astronauts & Jack Kirby's New Gods.
-
-
4. Remember Middlemarch? Dorothea Brooke falls for Mr. Casaubon, a venerable scholar who thinks he's discovered "the key to all mythology" but turns out to be a musty fraud. Already in 19th century, mythologists seemed a little quaint.
Show this thread -
4. Despite George Eliot's attempt to deflate with wit, mythologists continued to gain speed in 20th century, in part because it was a tradition that seemed to offer alternative to fraying social order of modernity.
Show this thread -
5. Many leading 20th century mythologists -- Jung, Eliade, Joseph Campbell -- leaned towards the far right (sometimes to fascism). This wasn't an accident: mythologist were searching for a replacement of natural theology to shore up hierarchy & fend off egalitarianism
Show this thread -
6. The Nazi fascination with occultism & with myth (which provided fodder for some of the Indiana Jones movies) was a popular manifestation of the same tendency.
Show this thread -
7. Of course, it's possible to take the same set of ideas & use them for other purposes. One of the achievements of Northrop Frye was that he took mythologist tradition of Jung & showed it could be progressive if you see myths as made culture, not timeless truths
Show this thread -
8. As per Frye: we inherit myths & archetypes but we also remake them. Blake turned the Devil into a hero, feminists like Kristin J Sollee turned witches into heroines. In Frozen, the traditional Disney witch-character (Elsa) is most loved character.
Show this thread -
9. Myths aren't static & univocal (as Paterson treats them) but, like all cultural artifacts, contested, fluid & polyphonic. Frye showed this on a theoretical level, Jack Kirby through his art.
Show this thread -
10. Running through Kirby's work is a fascination with myths, not seen as simply inherited things but open to renovation: mythology fusing with science fiction in stories of Ancient Astronauts (taken as much from pulps as von Danikens pseudo-science)pic.twitter.com/hWpZXL2t6l
Show this thread -
11. It's the fusion of science fiction with mythology that saves Kirby from the musty, status-quo loving traditionalism of the older mythologists: the New God embody older archetypes but also, crucially, contemporary uncertainty & anxiety.
Show this thread -
12. I have more thoughts along this line here:https://newrepublic.com/article/148473/jordan-petersons-tired-old-myths …
Show this thread
End of conversation
New conversation -
Loading seems to be taking a while.
Twitter may be over capacity or experiencing a momentary hiccup. Try again or visit Twitter Status for more information.