1. So the whole discussion of "intellectual dark web," conservatives in liberal media etc. confuses two issues: should non-conservatives read right-wing authors (yes) & should liberal magazines publish right-wing authors (it depends).
-
-
4. Buchanan & Francis are & were (Francis died in 2005) undeniably bigots but they also had a finger on pulse of where the American right was going.
Show this thread -
5. Should liberal (or mainstream/centrist) publications give space to writers like Buchanan & Francis? Hard to how, since even right found them unpalatable (Buckley denounced Buchanan's anti-Semitism, Washington Times fired Francis).
Show this thread -
6. Traditionally liberal (or mainstream/centrist) publications prefer to hire conservatives who are less rabid, saner, more palatable to wider audience (Will, Brooks, Douthat). Writers who most worth reading for ideas but not necessarily representative of the right.
Show this thread -
7. Contra Douthat, these institutions are not ideological capacious. They range from center right to center left.https://twitter.com/DouthatNYT/status/994964671752032256 …
Show this thread -
8. The problem all along is how do you represent the ideological divisions of polarizing & fraying America in institutions that really have a hard time processing ideas outside narrow center left & center right spectrum.
Show this thread -
9. Unpopular opinion but I think
@DouthatNYT has emerged as particularly valuable writer in Trump era because he can translate (so to speak) paleo-conservative impulses into language non-conservatives can understand.Show this thread -
10. Bari Weiss, viewed charitably, is trying to something similar to what
@DouthatNYT does: act as translator/mediator between right-wing subcultures and NYT centrist/liberal subculture. But these translation/mediations are always fraught.Show this thread -
11. Douthat's notorious robot sex column can be seen as case where translation/mediation failed because readers took him as sympathizing with incels & trying to mainstream their concerns. That's usual danger of liminal figure; to be seen as representing other side.
Show this thread
End of conversation
New conversation -
-
-
But it's just as important to read persuasive conservatives, not for insight into the RW mob, but as a proving ground and sharpening stone for your own ideas.
Thanks. Twitter will use this to make your timeline better. UndoUndo
-
Loading seems to be taking a while.
Twitter may be over capacity or experiencing a momentary hiccup. Try again or visit Twitter Status for more information.