1. This is spot on. For centuries novelists -- running from Sterne and Austen to Dickens to Bellow, Roth & Roupenian have had a monopoly power on parodying their family, lovers & friends. Now people have more power to strike back!https://twitter.com/SamAdlerBell/status/1413342298025435145 …
-
-
3. Mrs. Seymour Hill read David Cooperfield in serialization & objected to the cruel jokes about her appearance and the suggestion in the novel that she procured young women for aristocrats.
Show this thread -
4. Hill to Dickens, 1849: "you shew up personal deformities with insinuations that by the purest of my sex may be construed to the worst of purposes." Amazingly, Dickens took the criticism to heart & changed the characterization of Miss Mowcher in later chapters.pic.twitter.com/g8cQJGBE3a
Show this thread -
5. Dickens of course was a popular entertainer & unusually responsive to reader complaints (he also, in answer to Jewish readers who complained, toned down the anti-Semitism a little in Oliver Twist & later created, as redress, positive Jewish characters).
Show this thread -
6. The thing is a roman a clef is more like a caricature than it is polemic. You can answer a polemic -- how do you respond to mimicry exaggerated likeness?
Show this thread -
7. A Saul Bellow story is instructive. The critic Hilton Kramer was big Saul Bellow booster until Bellow put him as a character in Humboldt's Gift. The likeness was, in many ways, unfair, but also (if you know what a stuffed shirt Kramer was) hilarious.
Show this thread -
8. Jospeh Epstein, who had been friends with both Bellow & Kramer but broke with Bellow, tried to respond to Humboldt's Gift with a story about the affair, but the odd things is that in the story the Kramer character seems much worse than the Bellow!
Show this thread
End of conversation
New conversation -
-
-
Wasn't she the hairdresser?
-
Hairdress & pimp. Read between the lines.
- Show replies
New conversation -
Loading seems to be taking a while.
Twitter may be over capacity or experiencing a momentary hiccup. Try again or visit Twitter Status for more information.