@HPluckrose Do you have any thoughts on the idea that there is no scientific basis for free will? Do you see any threat here to the foundation of liberalism and the high value it places on personal choice and individual liberty? (Paraphrasing @harari_yuval ‘Homo Deus’) peace 
-
-
Whoops! My apologies, thanks again for engaging.
-
I'm much more coming on ideologies, political or religious!

-
*forthcoming
End of conversation
New conversation -
-
-
I'm not too interested in economics but I find that our lack of libertarian free will affects very little practically. If you can explain some reasons why you think it might represent a threat to liberalism, I can respond to those, though.
-
If liberalism relies on us feeling like we have free will, even though we don’t, and by paying attention to our thoughts we can observe that we don’t even have the feeling, why go on pretending that we do? Is it that it’s just the best system of ethics available to us at present?
-
What are the reasons you feel liberalism relies on us feeling like we have libertarian free will?
-
I’m not sure that it does and I think there’s a chance I’m confusing modern and classical liberalism here. If not though, I’m curious what the ‘freedom’ in liberal ideals such as freedom of speech, freedom of the press, freedom of religion and free markets means.
-
Freedom of speech, press, religion, etc. are about a lack of real consequences for or prohibitions against these things. These real consequences and prohibitions exist regardless of the status of libertarian free will.
-
I think you might be conflating libertarian free will with freedom in general. People have various degrees of actual freedom. Libertarian free will is a deeper type of freedom. It's the idea that people could have done otherwise; that their choices are free from determinism.
-
Yes I think I may be too. Could we say then that even though I am not truly ‘free’ to choose how I vote, I feel better having had the feeling that I was free to choose how to vote and so we should continue on as such?
-
When you say "...I am not truly 'free' to choose how I vote," do you mean free to choose the way your brain produces the choice? Bc you can make free (as in unconstrained by outside forces) votes. They will just be ultimately caused by a long line of deterministic forces too
- 4 more replies
New conversation -
Loading seems to be taking a while.
Twitter may be over capacity or experiencing a momentary hiccup. Try again or visit Twitter Status for more information.