This all gets very complicated.https://twitter.com/transscribe/status/906534622175092737 …
-
-
And they simply can't be applied consistently because the underlying premise of SocJus is not based on principles but on identity & power.
Show this thread -
So an argument or analogy made for the ethical treatment of one group won't work if transposed to another. Yet, people keep trying.
Show this thread -
This is what would happen if SocJus ruled society. The rules would grow ever more complicated & change daily.
Show this thread -
We really do need simpler but consistent principles & like
@IonaItalia, I think they should be prioritise care/harm foundations.Show this thread -
A conservative argued to me that because conservatives hold all these values & liberals just the first two,conservatism is a fuller moralitypic.twitter.com/xv1V889nX9
Show this thread -
I don't agree. I don't think that because we have all of these foundations underlying our morality, it means they are all equally valuable.
Show this thread -
That seems to me like the naturalistic fallacy. It means that we need to understand them to reduce misunderstanding & accommodate them.
Show this thread -
But we can & should work out between us which of them to base society on & which to understand & make accommodation for in individual lives
Show this thread -
Sanctity/degradation, in particular, seems to me like something it's useful to understand in ourselves for the purpose of overcoming it.
Show this thread -
'Yes, I feel disgusted by this but does that make it morally wrong? Can I justify making laws around it using anything but my intuitions?'
Show this thread
End of conversation
New conversation -
-
-
That's because they're poorly defined garbage. Define a concept strictly, and it's useful. Failing that, it's rhetorical horseshit.
Thanks. Twitter will use this to make your timeline better. UndoUndo
-
Loading seems to be taking a while.
Twitter may be over capacity or experiencing a momentary hiccup. Try again or visit Twitter Status for more information.