thats not independent justification
That could be motivating it, yes, but what she's actually saying is 'show we differ mentally from fish without using biology.'
-
-
the claim that the mind is adapted is a just-so story if there's no evidence apart from the data the hypothesis was constructed to explain
-
No, I don't think. Tho 'mind' is very vague. The evidence of evolution of the brain is immense & supported from many different angles.
-
i don't dispute that the brain evolved
-
And what is the mind/brain relationship to you?
-
the mind is not physical
-
The state of the brain has an impact on the mind or not all?
-
it does
-
So we could agree that the mind is consequence of the brain's activity?
- 13 more replies
New conversation -
Loading seems to be taking a while.
Twitter may be over capacity or experiencing a momentary hiccup. Try again or visit Twitter Status for more information.