That would be beneficial for its own sake but it becomes more important when trying to draw moral lessons from history.
-
-
-
Whether its the late medieval Catholic church or women's status, you get a very different picture if you look at how lives were affected.
-
Than if you're looking at papal bulls & significant documents or laws.This tells us more about humanity which is the point of the humanities
-
One thing it's important to remember re: gender relations throughout history is most men & women lived v close together in very small spaces
-
It was Isobel Davis in 'Negotiating Patriarchy' I think who pointed out just how significant this was.
-
If you spend much time in one room with someone you have to stay with the rest of ur life, this is much more pleasant if they're happy.
-
Which sounds cynical but really lives were tied together so much more than they are now. You knew each other very well. Limited escapism.
-
Divorce was not an option & you can't go off & play video games leaving your wife watching TV in bed whilst on social media.
-
And utterly dependent on each other in a way we're not now. Housewifery really was a full time job just to have food & clothes.
-
So you knew each other very well & apart from natural human empathy, love & compassion, much motivation to keep each other happy.
-
So ppl who look back & see men had power to control almost everything their wives did & assume they'd have done that selfishly see it wrong.
-
Obviously if a man was a bastard & happy to live with a miserable, cowed slave, his wife had very little recourse. Laws needed changing.
-
But mostly ppl had to get through lives which were hard and they had to do it together & they felt love & loyalty & commitment.
-
And this worked out with varying degrees of success & there was community justice & strong expectations of not being a complete arsehole.
-
In communities where everyone was very close together, indications that one spouse was not caring for the other wld bring strong disapproval
- 18 more replies
New conversation -
-
-
If it's not to much to ask, would you please name 3 crucial reads that would help a person to see this bigger picture?
-
This is the thing. If you go for metahistories or sources which try to summarise a huge topic like the church or women, doomed to failure.
-
But if there is some period (in England) or topic you are interested in between 1300 and 1700, I can probably help!
-
If, for example, you are interested in looking beneath the Protestant narrative of the hideously corrupt late Catholic church?
-
Or you want to know how the Black Death briefly empowered women & what this meant for them in reality?
-
I'll take sources on both. Always looking for more good reads!
-
https://www.amazon.co.uk/Late-Medieval-English-Church-Vulnerability/dp/0300197128/ref=sr_1_1?ie=UTF8&qid=1493808719&sr=8-1&keywords=the+late+catholic+church+bernard … Katherine French, The Good Women of the Parish Judith Bennet, Medieval Women, Modern Women, Across the Great Divide
-
The latter is an essay in David Aers Culture and History 1350-1600: Essays on English Communities, Identities & Writing which is all great.
End of conversation
New conversation -
Loading seems to be taking a while.
Twitter may be over capacity or experiencing a momentary hiccup. Try again or visit Twitter Status for more information.