It exists as a story with many versions & changes. You seem to think of it as one pure, unchanging thing rather than something ppl make up
-
-
Which is your right but it doesn't outweigh the evidence that there are many versions & it keeps changing.Neither does saying it's pointless
-
Many version just expose the contradictions. Again, you think not being a Muslim means you're still a Muslim. All kinds of stupid.
-
You're advocating no true scottsman fallacy. If anything is stupid in this conversation, it's that. There is no perfectly true Islam.
-
If I put a sofa into a woodchipper until it's just millions of fibres, would that still be a sofa? It's not the NTS fallacy when it's true.
-
Islam isn't a sofa. It's a vast set of ideas and the word "Muslim" describes anyone who believes some set of them and self describes as one.
-
Also I don't care if you call liberal versions of Islam 'Islam' or not. The point is that reformers try to draw Muslims to it & that's good.
-
Theological, philosophical or semantic arguments abt what constitutes true Islam are academic at best for Non-Muslims.
- 9 more replies
New conversation -
-
-
No, that's what the believers think. Either you believe it's infallible or you don't. If you reject all that's in it you're no longer Muslim
-
I don't really care if Muslims or you claim certain branches aren't real Muslims. The fact is different ones exist & I like the liberal ones
-
You don't care yet this is the actual topic? By your reasoning, everyone can b a Muslim regardless of what they believe. It's immensely dumb
End of conversation
New conversation -
Loading seems to be taking a while.
Twitter may be over capacity or experiencing a momentary hiccup. Try again or visit Twitter Status for more information.