Never claimed atheists were immoral. The concept of objective morality is incoherent if Atheism is true.
That's just human. If something is only real to one species on one planet, can it be objective?
-
-
Actually, yes. Key thing to remember is that "objective" only means "independent of the observer," or some such.
-
OK, if we're defining 'objective' as 'consistently true among homo sapiens' then moral emotions objectively exist
-
f every1 today thought the holocaust was good, nobody would feel it was wrong, but it still would be
-
What would say so?
-
I strongly suspect the Jews and gays that were killed would disagree. And they are the ones that would know.
-
But this is a hypothetical point. If everyone, inc victims, thought it good, humanity wld be unrecognisable.
-
I suppose, in that narrow case, I might find the Holocaust palatable. If all victims accepted it, then ...
-
What if all the victims were dead, but all brains still with signals thought it was OK? i need to get back to work...
- 21 more replies
New conversation -
Loading seems to be taking a while.
Twitter may be over capacity or experiencing a momentary hiccup. Try again or visit Twitter Status for more information.