GoingMadlem

I love reserved list arguments because nobody understands the underlying problems with abolishing the reserved list, why Legacy is bullshit, and how simple the problem is to fix without breaking the reserved list.

Let's start with Legacy... "the people's format"... you realize that for 15 years this format was just a joke that people told right? It was made up as a hypothetical retirement village for your old cards to still see play. "Type 1.5" was not something many cared about until...

... SCG resurrected the format to... drumroll please... SELL IRRELEVANT OLD CARDS THAT NOBODY WANTED TO BUY. Your precious dual lands are only worth money because SCG made them worth money. The format only exists in its current form because SCG spent years promoting it.

Nobody "needs" Black Lotuses (Loti?) to play Magic. Power 9 and a number of cards at that power level were mistakes. They should never be widely available because they are detrimental to the game and should be left in Magic's past... which leaves us with the crux of the RL...

Dual lands. Everyone "just wants to play legacy" and they need dual lands to do it. There are two diverging paths in this argument for me... 1. They can just print "better" dual lands in an ancillary product to make money and bypass this stupid fucking argument. Hexproof, etc...

2. The REAL issue is that making Legacy accessible is bad for business. Magic has lasted for so long because power creep ebbs and flows, but is ultimately zero. Wizards NEEDS rotating formats to maintain it's current business model. They're figuring out that Masters sets aren't..

..at all sustainable as a business model. Each subsequent release after MM2 has been a worse seller than the last (with 25 bucking the trend). Wizards can only print "old" cards for so long before they're just printing kindling. "They should adapt" you'll say...

... no you should adapt, OR recognize that this entire game is built on the backs of retailers and event organizers making money selling it. Stores don't run events for games they don't sell. If they do, they aren't stores long...