People ask this question a lot, and I think it's actually worth an answer, so my thoughts: Have lockdowns caused large numbers of excess deaths? 1/10 https://twitter.com/kknnaabb/status/1370949787084746752 …
-
-
3/10 What would we expect to see if lockdowns caused large numbers of deaths? Well, lots of COVID+lockdown would = many deaths, and no COVID+lockdown would ALSO = many deaths
Show this thread -
4/10 If COVID was relatively safe, and lockdowns harmful in the short term, we'd also expect to see that lots of COVID and NO lockdown would be associated with FEW deaths
Show this thread -
5/10 The first situation (COVID+lockdown) is obviously associated with many deaths. Tons of examples across the world to look at using this excellent paper on excess mortality https://www.medrxiv.org/content/10.1101/2021.01.27.21250604v1.full …pic.twitter.com/Fur9qsGvad
Show this thread -
6/10 However, when we look at NO lockdown, and lots of COVID, we see a similar issue. Lots of excess mortality that is probably down to the virus itselfpic.twitter.com/UjvnpXyzAS
Show this thread -
7/10 As for places WITH lockdowns and little/no COVID? Well, the numbers look very different. Few excess deaths if any at allpic.twitter.com/Pin1qsXpOY
Show this thread -
8/10 These numbers are pretty similar across different investigations of excess mortality - in fact, it appears that lockdowns where there's NO COVID are associated with ~fewer~ deaths that expectedpic.twitter.com/Bu3lKkTHw7
Show this thread -
9/10 This doesn't mean that lockdowns work, or that they're perfect, or any such nonsense It doesn't even mean that they definitely don't kill people (remember, short-term)
Show this thread -
10/10 It DOES mean that the best current evidence suggests that lockdowns in and of themselves are not associated with detectable increases in mortality They may even REDUCE deaths overall
Show this thread -
11/10 Small addendum - lockdowns could still be bad if they saved lives, the point here is that we are completely lacking the evidence that we'd expect to find if lockdowns caused many deaths as some claim
Show this thread
End of conversation
New conversation -
Loading seems to be taking a while.
Twitter may be over capacity or experiencing a momentary hiccup. Try again or visit Twitter Status for more information.