Now, I don't necessarily have a better way to do this - I mean, really, measuring how hot someone's tea is drunk? HARD - but this method has some clear elements of potential bias
-
-
This raises the last massive issue - residual confounding Note how the authors describe their findings vs the Daily Mailpic.twitter.com/iCvBZCoW0N
Show this thread -
"Substantially strengthen the association" is NOT THE SAME AT ALL as "see their risk of gullet cancer rise by 90 percent" (Also, lol, gullet cancer is a great name)
Show this thread -
Why are the authors so cautious Maybe it's because TEA DRINKING IS SUPER SOCIAL AND HARD TO UNPICK FROM CONFOUNDERS It's in caps because GODDAM IT I SAY THIS EVERY WEEKpic.twitter.com/GUAQyTAYof
Show this thread -
We can't exclude residual confounding. Maybe people drink tea differently in different social situations. Maybe hot tea is more often served with alcohol. Maybe a single measure of how hot people drink their tea isn't that great a predictor 10 years later when they get cancer
Show this thread -
Maybe there are a million factors you can never measure, and never control for, and thus it's really hard to know if this is causal or not Maybe
Show this thread -
So the authors are cautious. They know that there's a decent chance that the heat of your tea has nothing to do with risk of esophageal cancer But the newspaper needs a story And so we get "hot tea causes cancer"pic.twitter.com/g6kancVrKs
Show this thread -
So, let's recap: Large epi study showed 0.34% absolute increase in risk of cancer associated with drinking the hottest tea compared to cold tea, in large amounts, every day for 10 years Reverse causality and residual confounding remain an issue
Show this thread -
Do we trust these results? Well, yes. The study was interesting, and well done Do we think hot tea = cancer?
Show this thread
End of conversation
New conversation -
Loading seems to be taking a while.
Twitter may be over capacity or experiencing a momentary hiccup. Try again or visit Twitter Status for more information.