Gerard Killen

well if we didn't have it, we'd have £15bn to find this year...

I don't wanna argue over Gers cos I hate it. I don't think the methodology is the most efficient or accurate.

what's wrong with it?

when all it is evidence of is how poor Scotland's finances are managed whilst part of the union.

if it's not a true picture of where we'd be on independence, someone better tell us the secret to additional £15bn revenue.

as I've said many times,we wouldn't be spending on the same things in iScot so why futer aboot with figures that isn't representative?

really? So what would be cut? You know something Sturgeon doesn't? She refused to commit to cuts or tax rises. Head-in-sand mode

hmm I dunno, military weaponry, arms dealer lobbying, the lords? I'm sure there's a few savings that could be made ;)