To respond to Dr Tuller’s first question: how is FND different from other neurological disorders? In some ways, it’s not! It creates real disability, with symptoms often comparable to other neuro disorders like MS, and the source of that dysfunction is the brain.
-
-
Prikaži ovu nit
-
This is part of why some patients have argued against an exclusively psychological formulation: because it’s not just a subjective belief that you have, say, a gait disorder. You actually do.
Prikaži ovu nit -
IMO, FND should be all rights be a fully paid-up member of the Neurological Disorders Club. The fact that it isn’t (yet) widely recognized as such reflects a few differences: (FND experts, plz jump in here if I’ve erred or if you feel something I’ve said is not quite right)
Prikaži ovu nit -
1) FND has a different character than other neuro disorders. It’s not (directly) due to a pathogen, or genetic abnormalities, or autoimmune issues where your immune cells eat the myelin on your spinal cord or that kind of thing.
Prikaži ovu nit -
Following that, it’s not typically visible on MRI. My understanding is that’s because brain changes in FND at least typically begin at a micro level, too small for typical MRI to pick up.
Prikaži ovu nit -
Although both imaging technology and analysis techniques are getting better, and with these researchers are now able to examine differences at both the functional (micro) and structural (macro) levels. https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Voxel-based_morphometry …
Prikaži ovu nit -
(Neuroimaging is super not my strong point, so anyone with that background, please feel free to clarify or correct!) (
@JalilianRozita could perhaps speak to the specifics of this?)Prikaži ovu nit -
Anyway, neurologists are sometimes skeptical because FND symptoms can be “inconsistent”, which implies they’re not due to the same kind of permanent structural damage that you’d see with something like a brain lesion.
Prikaži ovu nit -
Then (and this is where I think the scales in many a doctor’s mind start to tip heavily) symptoms sometimes appear to be driven or influenced by psychological factors.
Prikaži ovu nit -
FND patients as a group have a very high rate of adverse life events, from neglect to abuse to physical injury and chronic pain. Although importantly not everyone seems to have a psychological history, which I think is significant.https://www.thelancet.com/journals/lanpsy/article/PIIS2215-0366(18)30051-8/fulltext …
Prikaži ovu nit -
So, having that picture: “inconsistent” + no findings on MRI + past history of mental illness seems to suggest to some neurologists that this is REALLY a fully psychological disorder, AKA not a neurological one...
Prikaži ovu nit -
AKA a problem of the mind not the brain, and thus not my problem, please go find someone else to fix your crazy. We’ll leave the stigmatizing attitude re: mental illness for another time...
Prikaži ovu nit -
But it’s not fully psychological anyway! And that’s what I mean by saying that FND is bigger than either psychiatry or neurology. “Fully psychological” also doesn’t explain how people develop these symptoms after injury, as I and many others have. https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/m/pubmed/24439198/# …
Prikaži ovu nit -
So what is functional neurological disorder, then? The evidence suggests that it’s a (yes) neurological disorder, and that the dysfunction lies in multi-modal brain networks at the top of the neural hierarchy.
Prikaži ovu nit -
Part of this is the so-called “limbic system”, which classically has been associated with emotions. AHA! PSYCHOLOGICAL!
(hang on)Prikaži ovu nit -
But it turns out the brain systems affected in FND also handle everything from motor control to attention to memory and visual perception and monitoring the state of the body (the interoceptive network). Multi-modal brain networks.
Prikaži ovu nit -
So that reflects a general truism of the brain, which is that most brain areas don’t do one dedicated thing, they do like 9 different things. That’s prob why people can develop the same neurological symptoms from a nasty divorce or a car accident: https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/m/pubmed/29868890 …
Prikaži ovu nit -
Because there are *no exclusively emotional networks in the brain*. A physical or emotional disruption can produce the same symptoms because they screw up the same brain networks, which are doing multiple things at once.https://m.youtube.com/watch?v=9pc8bCDm32U …
Prikaži ovu nit -
So that requires us to recognize that a psychological stressor need not be present for someone to get FND, but also acknowledge that it can happen that way, and that the disorder is sensitive/responsive to both emotional and sensory stimuli.
Prikaži ovu nit -
That also explains why symptoms can be “inconsistent”: it’s not the same as a lesion in motor cortex, which in one spot would reliably impair your ability to say, move your left leg. The problem is higher up in the hierarchy, in the areas that govern deployment of other systems.
Prikaži ovu nit -
(Specifically these areas are concerned with attention and action initiation)
Prikaži ovu nit -
That also explains why symptoms can recede with distraction: because you’ve momentarily occupied the dysfunctional parts of the brain with something else, and they’ve stopped interfering with the normal operations of the hierarchically lower areas.
Prikaži ovu nit -
Like when a micromanaging boss takes the day off and everyone gets more productive.
Prikaži ovu nit -
That attentional-emotional-bodysensing character is also why symptoms that seem really different, like certain types of tremors and paralysis and seizures and speech difficulty, frequently co-occur in the same patients, + are considered symptoms of FND.
Prikaži ovu nit -
Because they share common qualities reflecting a shared underlying dysfunction in the same brain networks.
Prikaži ovu nit -
From a patient perspective, this updated understanding of the brain also tends to make sense. It jives with our stories and experience of how the disorder started: usually some disruptive episode amplified by attention towards the body. And then we couldn’t get un-stuck.
Prikaži ovu nit -
From a not-patient perspective, many of our stories conversely slot nicely into how computational approaches to the brain theorize how these things might happen. It all starts to come together.
Prikaži ovu nit -
(Andy Clark
@fluffycyborg and Karl Friston have both written on this) https://academic.oup.com/brain/article/135/11/3495/270457 … https://global.oup.com/academic/product/surfing-uncertainty-9780190217013 …Prikaži ovu nit -
Regarding “structural vs functional”: FND is at LEAST a functional disorder, and appears to be in some cases a structural one. The question is “why would it be structural?”
Prikaži ovu nit -
There isn’t a definitive answer to this yet, but one possibility is that the structural changes develop out of the initial functional ones.
Prikaži ovu nit - Još 10 drugih odgovora
Novi razgovor -
Čini se da učitavanje traje već neko vrijeme.
Twitter je možda preopterećen ili ima kratkotrajnih poteškoća u radu. Pokušajte ponovno ili potražite dodatne informacije u odjeljku Status Twittera.