THREAD: Okay we HAVE to talk streaming numbers reporting because it seems like every few weeks I see some insane number floating out there and it's like "every show we have was as big as the MASH finale!" The problem is these numbers are both meaningless and damaging.
-
-
Good for studios, right? Of course. But the unions realized that a long time ago and fought so that movies / shows also has back-end points that go into the union. I cannot overstate how critical this money is to their function.
Show this thread -
It goes right to health plans, protections, workman comp, general funds, and in short, it makes a film's success a success for everyone. But now here's where we get to the streaming of all of it.
Show this thread -
In streaming, there is no back-end. Netflix is not selling your show a hundred times over. It's not putting the movie in theaters. It doesn't have to do ANY of those things. It's producing a work they solely own and exhibit forever. A closed loop.
Show this thread -
Now, this is obviously a problem for hollywood's top talent, so what it means is that prospective back-end gets negotiated up front and put into their fee (hope you have a good agent!).
Show this thread -
But the real ones suffering are the unions and smaller artists, especially ones who make sudden runaway "millions of people watching" shows. Without any backend, they're not seeing any financial part of the success they created.
Show this thread -
Which brings us to the age old wisdom of "that's fine, you get to renegotiate your new higher salary next time when the contracts up!" Only the streamers, particularly netflix, aren't doing that.
Show this thread -
They're cancelling hit and even modest hit shows the second new contract negotiations come up. Some of this has to do with their creative philosophy (or the lack), but they're moving onto other cheaper artists / whatever fresh new thing.
Show this thread -
Likewise, you can have a show that's actually a modest hit and when contract negotiations come up they can say "sorry, four people watched your show" and then underpay you even if work is actually doing really well for them.
Show this thread -
And for the big guns, it means they make up the viewer stats and can say 2 billion people watched a show and by the time they have to "pay" the artists for those 2 billion eyeballs, they're not going to.
Show this thread -
Sure, the people at the very top will be "fine," but they're also buying into their own shelf-life and diminishing the overall ability for almost all other artists to join in profit sharing (again, the no union backend is the real killer).
Show this thread -
Point is this: the nielsens were a wonky system for a million reasons I don't have time to get into (I mean, the studios were the ones paying them soooo) but having an even semi-democratic reporting system on artistic success was critical. Same goes for box office.
Show this thread -
Because it provides the single most important factor of leverage for artists and unions to find some stake in their own success.
Show this thread -
But in a world where everything is turning to streaming and subscription models, the company cash flow now has nothing to do with your given success, so they paint you one way or the other to help their $$$ side.
Show this thread -
I understand some of what I'm saying is generalization and there's a lot of little finicky points in this. There are people are genuine damn experts in all of it (and fighting accordingly). But this is absolutely the broad strokes of what is happening.
Show this thread -
What's hilarious is the studios would have LOVED to have this years ago because it meant they wouldn't have to have shared backend, etc. But now we're undoing basically everything those artists and unions fought for.
Show this thread -
"But but but please tell me it's good for consumers?" Sorry, it just means your favorite shows are going to get cancelled more and for less good reasons. Also movies don't make economic sense for streamers soooooooo not looking great on that front either.
Show this thread -
Who is this ultimately good for? The answer, like most late stage capitalist developments, is always just the major streaming companies and that's it. So it may just seem like numbers reporting, but it's part of the ever-widening, horrifying jaw of the haves and have nots. END
Show this thread -
This is really important thing to add! The whole thing is it's not true. HBO will tell you that taking great shows past a couple seasons can ABSOLUTELY bring in new subs, in fact, it's the best way to do just that.https://twitter.com/SweetCammyMac/status/1354827525722140673 …
Show this thread -
Look at the ratings below for Game of thrones. The ratings for breaking bad got bigger with every season. It is absolutely CRITICAL for your business. So why isn't NETFLIX realizing that?https://watchersonthewall.com/game-thrones-breaks-new-viewership-record-season-8s-winterfell/ …
Show this thread -
The simple reason is because they haven't had a GREAT show yet that scaled up (outside of bojack, that went 6). It's mostly the mix of bad creative models and constantly misunderstanding their own data because they look at it from tech perspective over creative.
Show this thread -
I swear every time I see Netflix talk about their data it's like the scene in THE JERK where the gunman is shooting at Steve Martin and hitting the cans and he's like "He hates these cans!" No, people don't "prefer" two seasons of slapdash TV that peters out quick.
Show this thread -
What they love and have always loved, is living within the world of a show and inviting the characters into their home. This drives admiration, success, brand loyalty, and all the things that made so many cable channels a destination in the first place.
Show this thread -
Which is also why I don't talk about the business side a lot. Because the essential core of any business model still comes down to quality of product. Which is why I virtually spend all my time talking about the ways we can maybe kinda sorta hopefully make better media. Anyway.
Show this thread -
For convenience, I ended up putting this in essay form so it was easier to read and expanding on some points. Thanks!https://www.patreon.com/posts/46804164
Show this thread
End of conversation
New conversation -
Loading seems to be taking a while.
Twitter may be over capacity or experiencing a momentary hiccup. Try again or visit Twitter Status for more information.