Some try to explain this saying utopia has less drama than dystopia. But never explain a changing parameter with a constant factor.https://twitter.com/robinhanson/status/914504814712754177 …
-
-
Peter Hamilton's Commonwealth novels still do background Utopia very well (and focus on zombie invasions) but that is not easy.
-
It's ok to realize that you can't yet write good Utopia and prefer good dystopia to bad Utopia, and I think many SF writers made that choice
-
Okay, but that sounds like a constant factor, which can't explain changes over time.
-
No, I'm saying older writers made worse literary decisions (or older SF editors tolerated it more). I think that changed over time.
-
And the turning point for making better literary decisions was ~1816? And that insight has taken 200 years to slowly diffuse to writers?
-
Leaving aside the separate slow increase of pessimism and flashy cynicism, I also think writing slowly got better over last N-hundred years.
-
That theory explains a constant trend toward dystopia. But one needs to add more to explain the overall pattern that changes direction.
-
*shrugs helplessly* I was only around for the most recent part of it.
- 3 more replies
New conversation -
Loading seems to be taking a while.
Twitter may be over capacity or experiencing a momentary hiccup. Try again or visit Twitter Status for more information.