Opens profile photo
Follow
Dan Good
@Dgood73
NYC journalist turned book ghostwriter | Ken Caminiti book Playing Through the Pain | CASEY Award finalist, Publishers Weekly starred review
JournalistNew York, NYdangoodwriting.comJoined April 2009

Dan Good’s Tweets

New: Columbus designed a Black History Month cop car and put an MLK quote on it, "Be the peace you wish to see in the world." No historian I talked to, including the founding director of the King Papers Project, has ever seen this quote.
25
1,802
Show this thread
A twice-divorced huckster whose "university" was nothing but a fraud scheme has some ideas about family and teachers.
Quote Tweet
Trump issues another education position: “As part of our new credentialing body for teachers, we will promote positive education about the nuclear family, the role of mothers & fathers, and celebrating rather than erasing the things that make men & women different & unique.”
Embedded video
0:25
802.6K views
1
8
This system would allow the deserving players to smell the roses while they still can; keep fans engaged; and ensure that someone is elected each year without greatly expanding the number of enshrinees. A re-invigorated baseball hall of fame voting process. Can you imagine?
Embedded video
GIF
1
Show this thread
A “Top 2” system is *95% EFFECTIVE* at pinpointing those players who traditionally reach the hall of fame—and enshrining them years ahead of time without watering down election classes with unworthy candidates.
Embedded video
GIF
1
2
Show this thread
Under the "Top 2" system, from 1966-2019, only FIVE additional players not currently in the hall would have gotten their tickets punched over the course of 54 elections: Meanwhile, 50+ eventual hall of famers would have seen their wait times reduced by an average of eight years.
1
3
Show this thread
The "Top 3" system opened up the hall enshrinement to too many players. Players like Rod Beck, Jack Clark, Willie McGee, Phil Cavarretta and Marty Marion. Back to the drawing board ...
Image
1
Show this thread
My initial thought was that the hall of fame could annually enshrine the top three finishers in the BBWAA voting (and any others who top 75 percent). I ran that system from 1966 until today. Seemed like a great idea! But it didn't quite work.
Embedded video
GIF
1
Show this thread
Maybe something like basketball and football's quota system would be effective. Every year, a bunch of people are enshrined. The process is more powerful and less vindictive.
Embedded video
GIF
1
Show this thread
But what if there was another way to streamline the election process and cut down on wait times without watering down the hall with unworthy candidates?
Embedded video
GIF
1
Show this thread
That got me thinking ... there's gotta be a better way. In some earlier years of the hall of fame, there was a runoff if no one reached the necessary 75 percent. Red Ruffing was elected that way in 1967.
Embedded video
GIF
1
Show this thread
Getting the 📲 after six votes isn't that bad. Ron Santo- 19 no votes. Elected after he died. Gil Hodges fell short 34 TIMES. Dick Allen fell just short of election during his lifetime. So many players wait for decades before getting enshrined. Rizzuto. Oliva. Kaat.
1
Show this thread
This was Scott Rolen's sixth year on the ballot. What made him more hall-worthy now as opposed to earlier years? And why, if he was always hall-worthy, do we need to wait so long to see him enter the hall of fame?
Image
1
Show this thread
Shutouts are bad. And they're also unnecessary. Here are the candidates who fell short in shutout years of 2021, 2013, 1996 and 1971, and their future outcomes. The earlier candidates all eventually made the -- these weren't unworthy candidates.
Image
1
1
Show this thread
When the BBWAA writers vote on MVPs and other yearly awards, they don't come back and say, "sorry, couldn't come up with a winner." And subsequently, not all MVP winners are viewed the same.
Image
Image
Image
1
1
Show this thread
The recent election bothered me. Not because I have a problem seeing Scott Rolen elected, but because we almost experienced *another* shutout. He only crossed the 75% threshold with five votes to spare.
Embedded video
GIF
1
Show this thread
Can't fully blame Pence for the documents mishap. He didn't realize they were bad until he found them alone in a room with a woman.
1
3
Petty rules are part of the problem. Players’ eligibility was reduced from 15 to 10 years, there’s a cumbersome process to become a hall voter, and writers are limited to 10 votes each year. wanted to keep Barry Bonds out. And in doing so, it tanked itself.
Embedded video
GIF
1
Show this thread
By failing to establish an enshrinement quota like other sports — say, at least five baseball players, managers or contributors added each year — and by limiting players' ability to get elected through BBWAA voting, continues to sink further into irrelevance.
Embedded video
GIF
1
Show this thread