Conversation

Feb 7, 2021

Agreed. Letter to someone about the copyright of their contributions? Sure, whatever, dispute it in civil. Letter to their university threatening legal action for personal-time contributions? That kind of behaviour is malicious.

Quote Tweet

Filippo Valsorda

@FiloSottile

Feb 7, 2021

Wow, I'm late to this, but having a lawyer send a letter to a student's university to try to get them in trouble for open source contributions they made on their own time is very not ok. twitter.com/renlord1/statu…

Replying to

For more context, this code was originally published by me under the Apache 2 license. Renlord ported my code to a newer version of Bionic libc. Copperhead is threatening him because they sell a product based on my work and are trying to retroactively claim ownership over it.

Replying to

and

There was never copyright assignment of my work to that company and in fact there was explicit agreement to the contrary. However, even if the copyright had been assigned to them, they cannot take back that this was released as open source code. It's just baseless intimidation.

5:23 PM · Feb 7, 2021Twitter Web App

Replying to

and

Meanwhile, they continue depending upon our open source work to build their closed source product, including work by Renlord and others that they've tried to intimidate. It really doesn't make any sense. They're taking our continued work on it while trying to stop it being made.

Replying to

and

If they actually succeeded at wiping out GrapheneOS, where are they going to get their code? Their actions are malicious as a whole rather than rational. Copperhead is controlled by someone with severe narcissistic personality disorder. They never had to start a conflict at all.