Conversation

Replying to
They want those devices to intercept *unencrypted* data without getting warrants. In many cases, companies grant access without a warrant anyway. The solution is not sending / receiving sensitive unencrypted data. The carrier has access no matter what and likely logs it all.
1
Replying to and
They are often required by law to keep logs of call metadata and SMS metadata and content at a minimum, for a certain amount of time. They could keep more and can keep it for longer in most cases if they want. You are trusting the employees at that company, their partners, etc.
1
Replying to and
If you're in a position where having the data intercepted locally is concerning, then you're already doing it wrong and should be concerned since the data is inherently visible to the carrier and anyone with access to their network. Law enforcement is one possibility among many.
1
Replying to and
Carriers often sell access to people's location and other sensitive data. They don't just give it to law enforcement without a warrant. They'll happily sell it to advertising firms, etc. for various purposes. Local interception shouldn't concern you much. It changes very little.
1
Replying to
Work profiles are a standard Android feature implemented in the Android Open Source Project. The app you're linking simply acts as a device admin to use work profiles for something they're not well suited to doing. I'm not really a fan of half-baked implementations of features.
1
Replying to and
It simply makes no sense to implement this kind of isolated profile via a device admin along with the massive limitation of only being able to have one isolated profile per user profile. It won't mix well with the proper use case for the feature either since you can't use both.
1
Replying to and
When I said it wasn't in scope, I meant using the standard feature (work profiles) as a half-baked sandbox implementation. This isn't how I approach things with my work. I don't think it should be done at all if it's not going to be done well. User profiles work better for this.
2