This requires more explanation. I look at magazines and journals very much like I look at colleges and universities. I compare the intellectual freedom of pundits to the academic freedom of professors. /2
-
Show this thread
-
At explicitly mission-focused institutions like, say, a Christian college, academic freedom is represented by the freedom to express views within the (at the best institutions) broad boundaries of the specific intellectual and spiritual tradition. /3
5 replies 6 retweets 53 likesShow this thread -
For an analog, think of National Review. We have tremendous liberty to express our views within the broad conservative intellectual tradition. But if I want to leave the conservative tradition, I should work elsewhere, and NR would be wise to ask me to leave. /4
10 replies 6 retweets 62 likesShow this thread -
Within the mainstream academy, however, the tradition is very different. Once you meet the intellectual and ethical threshold for hiring, your freedom is considerably greater. There is no “view” that is cause for firing. /5
9 replies 6 retweets 48 likesShow this thread -
For example, when I was president of FIRE, I worked many, many hours defending the academic freedom of Ward Churchill, the prof who called the 9/11 victims “little Eichmanns” — comparing innocent victims to a heinous Nazi architect of the Holocaust. /6
8 replies 9 retweets 60 likesShow this thread -
This is a vital exercise because it is critical that our culture contain intellectual spaces where smart people can write/think not without fear of criticism and vitriol but without fear of termination. If their skin is thick enough, they can do the work. /7
6 replies 10 retweets 84 likesShow this thread -
But it’s _hard_ to operate a truly free intellectual enterprise. It requires actual, true tolerance — meaning tolerating ideas and people you actually despise — and it means defending the rights of others you’d like to exercise yourself. /8
11 replies 22 retweets 92 likesShow this thread -
Ideally, we would have a robust intellectual environment where there are ideological institutions on the right and left, but there are also institutions dedicated to creating the kind of spaces that mainstream universities are supposed to create — centers of free inquiry. /9
3 replies 10 retweets 78 likesShow this thread -
But in our extremely polarized times, centers of free inquiry are truly hard to find. Instead, we have counterfeits — or (like I think happened at The Atlantic) institutions that wanted to give it a shot but couldn’t take the heat. /10
10 replies 14 retweets 97 likesShow this thread -
So, here we are. We’ve got media on the right, like NR, media on the left, like Mother Jones, and more media on the left that’s long been left-leaning but not specifically ideological. Now it is. It’s gone the way of the academy. The polarization is nearly complete. /end
45 replies 20 retweets 134 likesShow this thread
>We’ve got media on the right, like NR



Loading seems to be taking a while.
Twitter may be over capacity or experiencing a momentary hiccup. Try again or visit Twitter Status for more information.