Next level is that there are factors that really *can't* be explained in terms of individual incentives Why did AHA push low fat / high carb? Why did all of USG do so? The original tweet claims the solution to this riddle is coordination for the profit of pharma / fast food 2/x
-
-
Show this thread
-
The original tweet's explanation at least it notices that there's some bit that needs explaining beyond what individual incentives explains. Unfortunately the original tweet is basically "folk Marxism" and hence wrong because based on a wrong model. 3/x
Show this thread -
The Marxist bit is the belief that coordination can happen to drive a social outcome where everyone involved works on behalf of a nebulous "capitalist class" when this is flatly impossible because that type of coordination can't happen - merchants don't cooperate like that 4/x
Show this thread -
Merchants constantly undercut each other and "defect" on each other by competing in a market but ideologues - priests, on the other hand, do cooperate like that. People driven by ideology can and do cooperate to push social changes. 5/6
Show this thread -
So USG pushes high carb / low fat specifically because it's bad for you because it also makes men less masculine. IOW, it's an example of the Stonetoss comic and not strictly a market outcome but the mistake is identifying it as being done for profit. 6/6pic.twitter.com/mHydA7bkG2
Show this thread
End of conversation
New conversation -
Loading seems to be taking a while.
Twitter may be over capacity or experiencing a momentary hiccup. Try again or visit Twitter Status for more information.