I'm at something of a crossroads with respect to my content (I'm mostly known for criticizing the Alt Right, but feel I've said what I have to say on that for now) and my audience/approach (am I an engaging-the-other-side person or a fostering-a-safe-space person?).
-
-
(I don't know why people think that shit they say about me in "private" discord servers won't be screenshotted and sent to me lol)
Show this thread -
And it's funny, because I thought I'd get more leeway with this kind of thing when I came out as trans. "I'm recognized as a member of a marginalized group"—I very dumbly thought—"leftists will be more trusting of my good intentions." Exactly the opposite has happened.
Show this thread -
My perception, anyway, is that I'm now held to a 10x higher standard. We kind of expect cis white guys to fuck up a lot, to have grandiose debates with dinguses. And we're more forgiving of their shenanigans. A trans woman is expected to be perfect. So it currently seems to me.
Show this thread -
Now I don't want to imply that people who side eye me when I talk to certain people are all just over-sensitive or unreasonable. Actually I very thoroughly get it. A lot of my audience belongs to groups that YouTube is often a very bad experience for.
Show this thread -
It's not just a matter of my "talking to people who disagree." A lot of anti-SJW YouTube (just one example but a big one) has spent years leading nasty, personal campaigns to defame, hurt, and humiliate individual people in my community.
Show this thread -
So anything I do to appear chummy with people who have behaved that way, or are publicly friends with those people, makes me look like an alibi. An enabler. An apologist. Someone, at least, willing to associate with people who have caused a lot of pain (& are in denial about it).
Show this thread -
Now for me, personally, engaging those people isn't a big strain on my mental health. I find it helps—makes me safer online, even—to show up on those platforms & just be like "hi, I'm a human being, it's possible to have a conversation with me."
Show this thread -
What is a strain, however, is feeling like I'm potentially betraying people who've put their trust in me and hurting people I don't want to hurt e v e r y time I do this.
Show this thread -
It's a weird paradox, because I'm now in a situation where I could just choose to appear on pretty much any right-wing YouTube channel I want. I'm constantly invited to debates by everyone from centrist liberals to outright fascists.
Show this thread -
Paradox because I now have the opportunity to do exactly what I wanted to do when I started. But I'm no longer sure it's the right thing to do.
Show this thread -
The latest thing is I've been invited to do this
#kilroyevent, which includes some people I like and have spoken with before, and at least one person who's an outright fascist.Show this thread -
This is an event that Richard Spencer is (I hope fruitlessly) trying to worm his way into—he's not doing well lately, and this would benefit him. Would it benefit me? For starters, it'd be a nightmare for my relationship with my audience.
Show this thread -
Though it does annoy me that a lot on the left attack both 1. right-wingers for being in an echo chamber and 2. left-wingers who breach the right-wing echo chamber.
Show this thread -
Personally, I wouldn't mind getting drunk with anti-SJW YouTube after hours and asking everyone what their deal is. What do they want? What are they worried about? What are their dreams?
Show this thread -
But this decision is not mainly about my private thoughts and feelings. It's about how things look to spectators. And I don't know what to do, I'm never confident about these decisions anymore.
Show this thread -
End thread. Stream of consciousness over for now. Gotta edit my fucking video.
Show this thread
End of conversation
New conversation -
Loading seems to be taking a while.
Twitter may be over capacity or experiencing a momentary hiccup. Try again or visit Twitter Status for more information.
Business email: info@contrapoints.com