This is messy so strap in. [cw transphobia] Singal was inspired to begin his career as a cis commentator on trans people when he read cis journalist Alice Dreger's book "Galileo's Middle Finger," a defense of Blanchardism (a defamatory quack theory of MtF transsexuality).
-
-
They don't understand that they're exacerbating the very problems they claim to want to fix. This is not how journalism about trans people should be done in Current Year. Non-transphobic editors should not hire journalists who write like this.
Show this thread -
Let's close with an open letter to
@jessesingal: Jesse. Gurl. I don't know what your deal is or why you even care about any of this. I still appreciate the puff piece. You were friendly on Skype, though in retrospect I wonder if I was being observed like an insect in amber.Show this thread -
I've enjoyed talking to you in the past because I love having nuanced freespeechy conversations about philosophy of gender, MtF sexuality, detransitioners, and trans kids. But I often feel I cannot do that in public so long as the conversation is commandeered by people like you.
Show this thread -
There are many trans people who want to have these conversations, as well as cis people who approach us with more humility and patience than you and your predecessors. Please step down and let us have that.
Show this thread -
It's very difficult to have the nuanced conversations when you're under the heel of an oppressive political regime, hostile gatekeepers, condescending journalists. These are the circumstances that make us distrustful, that compel us to publicly huddle around unified ideology.
Show this thread -
In private I've found that any three trans people have four different ideas about what being trans even means. We're not a delusional hivemind. We're fully able to lead this conversation. Your input has not been helpful. Let us take it from here. Really, we've got it.
Show this thread -
Thread on Jesse Singal: https://threadreaderapp.com/thread/1034163389604552704.html …
Show this thread
End of conversation
New conversation -
Loading seems to be taking a while.
Twitter may be over capacity or experiencing a momentary hiccup. Try again or visit Twitter Status for more information.
Business email: info@contrapoints.com