I'm a conscientious objector to Twitter callouts. I think the less tweeted the better. But since my @verge profile is out and I'm already dragging Jesse Singal in print, here's a very Nuanced & Rational thread about why he's not a good commentator on trans issues.
-
-
The hyperbole of these accusations kept me in the dark about Singal longer than I should have been. In fact I don't feel I need to rescind anything I previously said about him. I said he's not a TERF (someone who cloaks transphobia in radical feminism). Well he's not.
Show this thread -
I do wish there were more of a commitment around here to being precise with callouts, to limiting accusations to what is strictly speaking true, instead of this raw expressionism. It's a distraction from what is *demonstrably* wrong with Singal. So here's the real T.
Show this thread -
This is messy so strap in. [cw transphobia] Singal was inspired to begin his career as a cis commentator on trans people when he read cis journalist Alice Dreger's book "Galileo's Middle Finger," a defense of Blanchardism (a defamatory quack theory of MtF transsexuality).
Show this thread
End of conversation
New conversation -
-
-
I feel like this tweet was an unnecessary shot. He's more than "kinda fucked up" and a lot of what you mention is people trying to make sense of his misinformation campaign about trans kids as well as his outright hostility to trans women who disagree with him.
-
This is one tweet in this otherwise good thread that I thought undersold Singal's fuckery. Lots of what has been said about him is terrible but not hyperbolic at all.
- 2 more replies
New conversation -
-
-
And the way he brought up Julia Serano in an article about trans kids and linked to an article she wrote about dating.
- 1 more reply
New conversation -
-
-
what’s an egg?
-
Someone who's trans but hasn't fully realized it yet.
- 1 more reply
New conversation -
-
This Tweet is unavailable.
Loading seems to be taking a while.
Twitter may be over capacity or experiencing a momentary hiccup. Try again or visit Twitter Status for more information.
Business email: info@contrapoints.com