I'm a conscientious objector to Twitter callouts. I think the less tweeted the better. But since my @verge profile is out and I'm already dragging Jesse Singal in print, here's a very Nuanced & Rational thread about why he's not a good commentator on trans issues.
-
-
Let's concede that many of the typical accusations are unsubstantiated or hyperbolic: that he's a TERF, a chaser, an egg, that he "wants trans people dead," that he's a pulsating hive of pure malevolence—you know, Twitter-speak for "he kinda fucked up."
Show this thread -
The hyperbole of these accusations kept me in the dark about Singal longer than I should have been. In fact I don't feel I need to rescind anything I previously said about him. I said he's not a TERF (someone who cloaks transphobia in radical feminism). Well he's not.
Show this thread -
I do wish there were more of a commitment around here to being precise with callouts, to limiting accusations to what is strictly speaking true, instead of this raw expressionism. It's a distraction from what is *demonstrably* wrong with Singal. So here's the real T.
Show this thread -
This is messy so strap in. [cw transphobia] Singal was inspired to begin his career as a cis commentator on trans people when he read cis journalist Alice Dreger's book "Galileo's Middle Finger," a defense of Blanchardism (a defamatory quack theory of MtF transsexuality).
Show this thread
End of conversation
New conversation -
Loading seems to be taking a while.
Twitter may be over capacity or experiencing a momentary hiccup. Try again or visit Twitter Status for more information.
Business email: info@contrapoints.com