@drcmday watched GMC v Bawa-Garba in High Court and has written a blog about the way the GMC chose to argue the case against a junior doctor convicted of manslaughter for a medical error in the context of multiple system failures & errors from other staff
http://54000doctors.org/blogs/whose-interests-are-the-gmc-really-trying-to-serve-in-the-bawa-garba-case.html …
And 2 more questions, if I may Chris: "GMC accepted that not all doctors who are convicted of gross negligence manslaughter should be struck off." > Accepted because of what argument? > Are there currently any clinicians still registered, who have been convicted of this charge?
-
-
From what the GMC stated in court it would indicate that there are doctors with manslaughter convictions that a FTP panel found no impairment of FTP going forward or after a sanction such as suspension. That's what makes their actions with Dr
#BawaGarba all the more concerning. -
Wow. So everybody's going crazy about insisting 1 doctor must be struck off for being convicted of manslaughter, but there are others who previously haven't been? So where was the coverage of those cases? Did I miss them?
-
Sorry Anne, it's only just dawned on me that you're referring to the Dr Freda Mulhem case. Just a 12 month suspension by GMC there. Why is that manslaughter conviction any less damaging to public confidence than
#BawaGarba, one wonders? -
15 years ago the landscape was much less adversarial, legalistic, and dare I say blaming Recently the default has become that the doctor is at fault until proven otherwise. Perhaps .
@jeremy_hunt as Our Dear Leader for most of that time might know why this change has occurred -
You could argue that I'm a part of that 1st paragraph shift. Though not by choice, I promise you. But the 2nd paragraph would not be in keeping with my experience I'm afraid. On the contrary in fact. Whatever's changed, I haven't felt it yet.
-
I’ve been around long enough to qualify as a cynical old mare. I imagine a black Muslim female dr who failed in her duty to save a cute white child is doomed in the ‘court of public opinion’. Which the GMC is obliged to take account of, under the euphemism ‘public confidence’
-
That would almost smack of deferring to mob rule. I sincerely hope there's something more lawfully robust than just appeasing a crowd behind such cases. Especially one as unpleasant as that might imply.
- 11 more replies
New conversation -
Loading seems to be taking a while.
Twitter may be over capacity or experiencing a momentary hiccup. Try again or visit Twitter Status for more information.