1/6 Have been thinking about Thucydides "Fear, Honor, and Interest" quote. Poked around the Greek a bit, but I'm not an expert by any means in Ancient Greek, and would like others to comment. But some thoughts.
-
Näytä tämä ketju
-
2/6 Fear, as my colleague Bret Devereux reminded me, is not the knee-jerk flail, so much as a decent respect for the possibility of attack by others. A pre-emptive weather eye, if you will. Not a big surprise.
1 vastaus 0 uudelleentwiittausta 3 tykkäystäNäytä tämä ketju -
3/6 Honor is partly "esteem"--how one is seen in the eyes of others, but it is even more "reputation." That is, do you fulfill your obligations and take necessary revenge. Reputation is part of how you manage how many other states you have to fear! Better reputation--Less fear.
1 vastaus 0 uudelleentwiittausta 3 tykkäystäNäytä tämä ketju -
4/6 Interest is where it gets interesting. It's often viewed as "Power-seeking" or profits seeking. It is in our "interest" to expand; to be powerful, and therefore we do. But the word "ophelias" is most often used in Thucydides to imply "help" or "aid" esp. in war.
1 vastaus 0 uudelleentwiittausta 2 tykkäystäNäytä tämä ketju -
5/6 Is it possible that Thucydides here meant that one of the 3 main reasons one went to war was in aid of others? of allies? And thereby you helped your honor/reputation? Greek specialists dig in! Thuc. 1.75.3 and 1.76.2 (interest as used at 1.75.5 is a whole other word)
3 vastausta 0 uudelleentwiittausta 2 tykkäystäNäytä tämä ketju -
Vastauksena käyttäjälle @MilHist_Lee
In Polybius ὠφέλεια can mean 'spoils' or 'loot' which would seem to run the other way (though Polybius is much later, of course).
2 vastausta 0 uudelleentwiittausta 1 tykkäys -
Vastauksena käyttäjille @BretDevereaux ja @MilHist_Lee
For my own part, I think honor covers alliances (though that may just be all of the Romans in my head shouting 'fides!' a lot). For the Greeks, I think a lot of honor comes down to both sides of the common Greek moral imperative to "help friends and harm enemies."
1 vastaus 0 uudelleentwiittausta 2 tykkäystä
And so includes both vindictive revenge on one side, and stalwart defense of allies on the other (though to be frank, few Greek states seem to me to have been very reliable allies in the long run. Greek diplomacy is just kind of awful, even by ancient standards).
-
-
Vastauksena käyttäjälle @BretDevereaux
Honor/reputation/credibility may indeed cover alliances. That's fair. (and it certainly includes "do all harm/do all good" ethic.) I'm much more interested in the nuance around "interest"
0 vastausta 0 uudelleentwiittausta 0 tykkäystäKiitos. Käytämme tätä aikajanasi parantamiseen. KumoaKumoa
-
Lataaminen näyttää kestävän hetken.
Twitter saattaa olla ruuhkautunut tai ongelma on muuten hetkellinen. Yritä uudelleen tai käy Twitterin tilasivulla saadaksesi lisätietoja.