Bret Devereaux

Which leads me to conclude that - whatever the skills of John Q Public - ancient farming methods appear to regularly have been performed by individuals whose nutrition was, at times, borderline.

Now, many hoplites - especially in front-rank or ekdromoi capacity - were not these marginal farmers. They were well-to-do, we know, because they had expensive armor & weapons. But we know those marginal farmers existed.

I think we can be pretty sure, for instance, that the enslaved laborers who yoked Cato the Elder's animals were not in optimal nutritional health, given what he tells us about how he fed, supplied and clothed them.

You're jumping all over the place here! We can't lump together modern ethnography, a Roman villa & classical hoplites Nutritional evidence from Rome by Killgrove shows huge disparities in diet b/t elite & poor. But Lagia shows much less nutritional inequality in classical athens

I'm trying to respond to a bunch of different points; hard to be clear w/ twitter. @NeolithicSheep is talking about basic farming tasks and suggesting they demand a high level of athleticism. I am point out that we know these were done by people in bad nutritional health.

Not a high level of athleticism, I am no triathlete and eg Myke can prob dead lift me. On the other hand, I know that I'm stronger than your average modern office worker and had better cardio endurance even before I got bored during the pandemic and took up jogging.

Were farmers using past tech universally well nourished? Demonstrably not. They prob also weren't hoplites. But on average I suspect you're underrating their physical abilities through unfamiliarity with what their routine tasks entailed.

I was only addressing your point that a "reasonably fit" modern person is in better shape than ancient people, I'm kinda dubious.