You're being a dick.
-
-
Antwort an @murnut @BrandonFugal und
I'm being realistic. Brandon knows there's trade-offs for doing a show like this. The producers need to give an entertaining narrative, with appropriate reactions, etc. Taylor, while no doubt being an actual scientist/engineer, is also great at working with producers.
2 Antworten 0 Retweets 1 Gefällt mir -
I strongly disagree w/the way you marginalize/diminish his credibility as both a scientist & objective observer/experiencer. You’d be hard pressed to find someone who is equally credentialed among the cacophony of critics. Plus he’s joined by 2 other legit scientists on my team.
3 Antworten 1 Retweet 20 Gefällt mir -
Antwort an @BrandonFugal @murnut und
Well the problem here is that his credibility, knowledge, and experience isn't really coming though in the show. You see hints of it, like when he express skepticism when that giant magnet was rolled out. But it's mostly hidden by the show's production.
3 Antworten 0 Retweets 4 Gefällt mir -
True - that is a legitimate criticism. The television medium has its challenges, but it also a powerful medium to inform the general public & stimulate interest and discussion.
1 Antwort 0 Retweets 15 Gefällt mir -
Antwort an @BrandonFugal @MickWest und
The TV medium may have that potential, but what actually happens, more often than not, is uncritical acceptance of subjective beliefs. From my seat, that’s much more of a cultural hindrance than positive contribution.
4 Antworten 0 Retweets 1 Gefällt mir -
Antwort an @TheUFOTrail @MickWest und
That’s a fair criticism. I can see your point of view. Give me some examples of truly positive contributions over the last 30 years that have truly advanced and elevated the discussion & research regarding these topics.
2 Antworten 0 Retweets 6 Gefällt mir -
Antwort an @BrandonFugal @MickWest und
IMO, such efforts typically don’t appeal to UFO enthusiasts because legit contributions must come at the topic without paranormal preconceived assumptions, but research into Hessdalen & Brown Mtn Lights come to mind. My 2 cents.
3 Antworten 0 Retweets 2 Gefällt mir -
Antwort an @TheUFOTrail @BrandonFugal und
Wow Jack- that sounds like a long way of saying “I can’t provide any examples”
1 Antwort 0 Retweets 1 Gefällt mir -
Antwort an @UAPmike @BrandonFugal und
Even if there were no examples of worthwhile contributions that are not credulous, which there are, it still would not justify rationalizing the stoking of unsupported assumptions. Entertainment & UFO ‘research’ are often thinly veiled exploitation.
3 Antworten 0 Retweets 0 Gefällt mir
Are you saying that our reported observations & data are “unsupported assumptions”?
-
-
Antwort an @BrandonFugal @MickWest und
Not necessarily in all instances, no. I was making a general statement about the typically poor quality of information portrayed on cable paranormal shows & such.
1 Antwort 0 Retweets 1 Gefällt mir -
Antwort an @TheUFOTrail @BrandonFugal und
What should change about the format? (I’ll probably agree.)
0 Antworten 0 Retweets 0 Gefällt mir
Ende der Unterhaltung
Neue Unterhaltung -
Das Laden scheint etwas zu dauern.
Twitter ist möglicherweise überlastet oder hat einen vorübergehenden Schluckauf. Probiere es erneut oder besuche Twitter Status für weitere Informationen.