Conversation

Frank Gorshin's Riddler appeared eight times in the show's first season and returned for a single episode in the show's third season following a length contract dispute. John Astin's Riddler, on the other hand, only appeared in a single episode in season 2.
  • Riddler (Frank Gorshin)
    87.7%
  • Riddler (John Astin)
    12.3%
81 votesFinal results
1
9
The Minstrel (Van Johnson) was an electronics genius with a lute. He was created for the series, but never appeared in the comic. Former med student Walter Slezak played the Clock King, uttering the immortal line: Some people kill time, but this time, time is going to kill you
  • The Minstrel
    25%
  • Clock King
    75%
64 votesFinal results
1
6
Mad Hatter's (David Wayne) first appearance saw him exact revenge on the jury that convicted him by stealing their hats. Actor Rudy Vallée (Lord Marmaduke Ffog) was described as "an absolute churl" on set while his co-star Glynis John (Lady Penelope Peasoup) "was a dream".
  • The Mad Hatter
    81.8%
  • Lord Ffog/Lady Peasoup
    18.2%
66 votesFinal results
False Face (Malachi throne) was credited as "?", leaving many to wonder whether Frank Sinatra had been behind the mask. The role of Minerva was originally intended for Mae West, while Zsa Zsa Gabor (who ultimately played the part) was slated to play Marsha Queen of Diamonds.
  • False Face
    46.6%
  • Minerva
    53.4%
88 votesFinal results
8