1/OK let's go through this @davidfrum article on immigration piece by piece.
Much of it is going to be totally wrong, but I want to give it its due...https://www.theatlantic.com/magazine/archive/2019/04/david-frum-how-much-immigration-is-too-much/583252/ …
-
Show this thread
-
2/Frum starts with the good old Europe Bait-n-Switch. He references an anti-immigration backlash in Europe as reason why immigration is dangerous. We're supposed to just assume America is like Europe.pic.twitter.com/lkT8hTrpqB
4 replies 24 retweets 180 likesShow this thread -
3/But of course the real thesis here is that Trump's election in 2016 was actually a referendum on immigration, so we need to bow to the Will of The People and cut immigration. Even though popular support for immigration is at all-time highs.pic.twitter.com/0t0Xey6c2x
7 replies 29 retweets 234 likesShow this thread -
4/Next comes nostalgia for a time that the left was anti-immigration (because I'm sure Frum is in favor of everything that Bernie Sanders was ever in favor of, right?):pic.twitter.com/sl1e0kwWXI
4 replies 15 retweets 150 likesShow this thread -
5/Frum then points out that the Scary Scary Caravan was, in fact, a real thing. He assumes that this means it really was Very Scary.pic.twitter.com/FgPq7pgHK4
3 replies 14 retweets 154 likesShow this thread -
#TestAndTrace Smith 🐇 Retweeted #TestAndTrace Smith 🐇
6/Of course, it wasn't scary, but whatever, right?https://twitter.com/Noahpinion/status/1054085360156700673 …
#TestAndTrace Smith 🐇 added,
#TestAndTrace Smith 🐇Verified account @Noahpinion1/With people freaking out about the Honduran migrant caravan now forcing its way through Mexico, I figured it might be time for a thread about Central American immigration. https://www.bloomberg.com/news/photo-essays/2018-10-21/migrant-caravan-continues-toward-u-s-even-as-trump-threatens-military-intervention …Show this thread5 replies 16 retweets 167 likesShow this thread -
7/Frum DOES get something right when he notes that rising living standards in poor countries are partly responsible for increased migration pressure. This is something few people realize. Migration pressure roughly tends to peak when a country reaches around $7000-$9000/person.pic.twitter.com/WggaUQD7cM
3 replies 29 retweets 211 likesShow this thread -
8/Frum notes that it's "the best-educated who yearn to leave" developing countries. Is this supposed to scare us??!pic.twitter.com/3hwLiOrqOs
16 replies 42 retweets 273 likesShow this thread -
Replying to @Noahpinion
Is there a halfway coherent argument hidden somewhere? Too large a brain-drain presumably will [further] destabilize countries over the long term, if the return rate is very low. Not sure if there's good data on this.
1 reply 0 retweets 1 like -
Replying to @AndresFreundPol @Noahpinion
Frum's immigration position has never made sense or was particularly well substantiated beyond a dubious will of the volk principle and he isn't about to change that now, it seems.
1 reply 0 retweets 0 likes
I agree on that. I was basically just wondering if he accidentally made a point on what I commented upon.
Loading seems to be taking a while.
Twitter may be over capacity or experiencing a momentary hiccup. Try again or visit Twitter Status for more information.