"Innovation," from the Latin innovare, innovatio, should signify renewal, rejuvenation from inside, rather than novelty, which is its modern meaning in both English and French. Judging from the Examples in the Oxford English Dictionary and the Littre, the word came into...
-
-
This process exactly reversed the earlier one, when the bad connotations rooted in theology extended to the non-theological uses of the word. As early as the beginning of the 19th century, innovation became the god that we are still worshiping today.
Show this thread -
The new cult meant that a new scourge had descended upon the world - "stagnation." Before the 18th century, "stagnation" was unknown; suddenly it spread its gloom far and wide.
Show this thread -
The more innovative the capitals of the modern spirit became, the more "stagnant" and "boring" the surrounding countryside appeared. As I said before, the negative view of innovation is inseparable from a conception of the spiritual and intellectual life dominated by stable...
Show this thread -
... imitation. Being the source of eternal truth, of eternal beauty, of eternal goodness, the models should never change. Only when these transcendental models are toppled, can innovation acquire a positive meaning. External mediation gives way to a world in which...
Show this thread -
.., at least in principle, individuals and communities are free to adopt whichever models they prefer and, better still, no model at all. This seems to go without saying. Our world has always believed that "to be innovative" and "to be imitative" are two incompatible attitudes.
Show this thread -
This was already true when innovation was feared; now that it is desired, it is more true than ever. The romantic historian puts innovation on a par with foundation and creation itself, the creation ex nihilo, no doubt, that, up to that time, had been exclusive monopoly of...
Show this thread -
... the biblical God. A complete break with the past is viewed as the sole achievement worthy of a "creator." Just as the measure of a painter's talent is now his capacity to innovate in painting, the measure of a lover's love is his or her capacity to innovate in the...
Show this thread -
... field of love-making. To be "with it" in the France of 1920, one had to be "innovative" even in the privacy of the boudoir. What a burden on all lovers' shoulders! Far from exorcising the urge to mimic famous lovers in literature and history, compulsory innovation can only...
Show this thread -
... inflame it further. This is how inconsistency has become the major intellectual virtue of the avant-garde. But the real credit for the tabula rasa school of innovation should go to Nietzsche, who was tired of repeating with everybody else that a great thinker...
Show this thread -
... should have no model. He went one better, as always, and refused to be a model - the mark of genius. This is still a sensation that is being piously repeated today. Nietzsche is our supreme model of model-repudiation, our revered guru of guru-renunciation.
Show this thread -
The emphasis on ruptures, fragments and discontinuitites is still all the rage in our universities. This extreme view of innovation has been dominant for so long that even our dictionaries take it for granted. Innovation is supposed to exclude imitation as completely...
Show this thread -
... as imitation excludes it. Examples of how the word should be used are of this type: "it is easier to imitate than to innovate." This conception is false, I believe, but its falsity is easier to show in some domains than in others.
Show this thread -
The easiest illustration is to be seen in contemporary market economies. This is certainly a domain in which innovation occurs on a massive, even frightening scale, at least in the so-called developed countries. It is not difficult to observe the type of behavior that fosters..
Show this thread -
..economic innovation. In Economics, innovation has a precise definition; it is sometimes the bringing of technical invention into widespread practical use, but it can also be improvements in production technique, or in management. It is anything as yet untried that gives...
Show this thread -
...a business an edge over its competitors. That is why innovation is often regarded as the principal, even the sole source of profits. Business people can speak lyrically about their mystical faith in innovation and the brave new world it is creating, but the driving force...
Show this thread -
... behind their constant innovation is far from utopian. In a vigorous economy, it is a matter of survival, pure and simple. Business firms must innovate in order to remain competitive. Competition, from the Latin words, cum and petere, means to seek together.
Show this thread -
What all businessmen seek is profits; they seek them together with their competitors in the paradoxical relationship that we call competitive. When a business loses money, it must innovate very fast, and it cannot do so without forethought. Usually there is neither money nor...
Show this thread -
... the time for this. In this predicament, business people with a strong survival instinct will usually reason as follows: "If our competitors are more successful than we are, they must be doing something right. We must do it ourselves and the only practical way to go about...
Show this thread -
... it is to imitate them as exactly as we can." This common sense makes less sense than it seems. To begin with, is there such a thing as "absolute innovation"? In the first phase, no doubt, imitation will be rigid and myopic. It will have the ritual quality of the external.
Show this thread -
After a while, however, the element of novelty in the competitor's practice will be mastered and imitation will become bolder. At that moment, it may - or may not - generate some additional improvements which will seem insignificant at first, because it is not suggested...
Show this thread -
.. by the model, but which really is the genuine innovation that will turn things around. I am not denying the specificity of innovation. I am simply observing that, concretely, in a truly innovative process, it is often so continuous with imitation that its presence can...
Show this thread -
... be discovered only after the fact, through a process of abstraction. Our age tries to overcome the modern obsession with the "new" through an orgy of casual imitation, an indiscriminate adoption of all models.
Show this thread -
We must observe that mimesis returns to us in a parodic and derisive mode that is a far cry from the patient, pious and single-minded imitation of the past. The imitation that produced miracles of innovation was still obscurely related to the mimesis of religious ritual.
Show this thread -
The real purpose of post-modern thinking may well be to silence once and for all the question that has never ceased to bedevil "creators" in our democratic world - the question of "Who is innovative and who is not?" If such is the case, post-modernism is only...
Show this thread -
... the latest modality of our romantic "false consciousness," one more twist of the old serpent. There will be more. - Some notes from "Innovation and Repetition" by Rene Girard
@MimeticValue@dopaminendreams@pmarca@startupdaemon@GirardForum@BrunoPerennou@tellfisherShow this thread
End of conversation
New conversation -
Loading seems to be taking a while.
Twitter may be over capacity or experiencing a momentary hiccup. Try again or visit Twitter Status for more information.