Conversation

I unapologetically view people who literally believe the stars/planets can predict unrelated things on earth as uniquely bad at thinking (moreso than many other strange beliefs) But if you don't literally believe this, then astrology seems like it could be really cool. 1/
35
557
There's a ton of strange 'power of mind' stuff that probably feels very much like magic, and might need to be approached in a frame of magic for it to work well (similarly how believing in jesus makes spiritual healing work better on you). But it's hard to strike a balance! 2/
2
130
As in it can be really hard to let multiple frames overlay your reality at once without picking the mystical one and letting it blend into the predictive one. Mystical experiences can be soul-shatteringly profound, and it's *hard* to not let it interrupt normal truthfinding. 3/
1
90
I don't mean to treat mystical experiences as untrue, but rather as a diff type of truth. They are fundamental, they are art, they are the fount of wisdom that can transform who you are, but they *aren't* good evidence for planets predicting the future. 4/
2
85
When I'm around people where I feel comfortable they know how to keep their frames separate, where understanding of physics remains intact, then I personally feel comfortable talking and interacting in very magical terms that would sound insane to outsiders. 5/
5
117
I think of it a bit like a computer; the "true nature" of the computer is incomprehensible ones and zeros in strange boards, but we interact with the "illusion" of the information on the screen. I'm comfortable interacting with illusions, knowing the true nature is 1s and 0s. 6/
5
136
and i wouldn't be surprised if we've only begun to tap the weird, cool shit we can do with the illusions on the screen. Experimenting with and investigating this - as long as it's done in harmony with predictive beliefs, not in dismissal of them - sounds really fascinating to me!
Replying to
This strikes me as a recipe for psychological compartmentalization. If you have a profound mystical experience it tends to Bleed into the rest of your life anyway including your epistemology and why shouldn't it?
1
1
Replying to
I think the placebo effect proves most of what the Bible is about is true. So…yes to your take, but also…the weird stuff is not an illusion. It’s just the unseen part of reality which is just as real as the ones and zeros. U have to let reality scale up as well as down.
Replying to
Recognizing that you already have multiple frames—and embracing that fact—is very liberating. I think harm has been done by the meme that magic (or placebo, for that matter) requires "belief" to function—make-believe is very effective and generally more reliable.
1
Replying to
This is a fascinating line of thought well worked out. More mind stuff that feels like magic: - massage. There is no way in the world someone else should be able to relax your muscles for you when you can't. 1/
1